Review by School Library Journal Review
Gr 4--8--In this graphic novel adaptation of Rhodes's acclaimed novel, readers meet the ghost of 12-year-old Jerome, a Black kid, as he navigates his untimely death at the hands of a white police officer. As a ghost, Jerome befriends the spirit of real-life victim Emmett Till, a Black boy who endured a similar injustice, and Sarah, the still-alive daughter of the police officer who killed him. Like the original novel, the adaptation tackles themes of police brutality, prejudice, justice, and other issues that remain relevant for readers across a range of ages. While it takes some time for the graphic novel to deliver the same emotional impact as the original novel, it ultimately succeeds, with Jerome's grief becoming raw and palpable. The artwork is at times abstract but always vibrant and puts a glowing aura around the ghost characters, which ultimately complements the story well. VERDICT Although the adaptation doesn't replace the original, it will introduce a whole new audience to this powerful and pivotal story.--Esther Keller
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
In this graphic adaptation of Rhodes' award-winning 2018 novel, the spirit of a 12-year-old, who was killed by a white police officer while playing outside, is tethered to that of other murdered Black boys. Jerome Rogers' parents work long hours, and his grandmother takes care of the house. He's a loving child who follows the grown-ups' admonitions as he walks to school with his sister through their perilous Chicago neighborhood. Being a good student makes Jerome a target for bullies, and he befriends new student Carlos, who's also a target. Carlos offers Jerome a toy gun to defend himself from his persecutors, a spontaneous gesture that has tragic consequences. Now a spirit who can only be seen by Sarah, the daughter of his killer, Jerome witnesses his family's agony while attempting to process his own grief and stolen dreams. The ghost of Emmett Till appears, showing Jerome his own story and telling him to "bear witness," but Sarah, who struggles with the fallout from her father's actions, doesn't know how to help. Fiadzigbey's panels are interestingly varied: On the opening page, readers look down from above as the cop stands over Jerome's small, dead body, unaware that Jerome's spirit is looking on, too. Paradis effectively uses colors to deepen the emotional impact of the text. Readers will emerge with a more nuanced view of the impact of generations of racism and the ways our actions affect our social systems. A layered exploration of grief.(Graphic fiction. 10-14) Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.