Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
What Blair deems the best erotic scenes in the last 50 years of American literature have been collected in this ambitious anthology, with some of the 46 sexy pieces excerpted from such classic novels as Saul Bellow's 1954 groundbreaking The Adventures of Augie March and Philip Roth's The Professor of Desire. There are contemporary scorchers as well, like Mary Gaitskill's "Processing," or A.M. Homes's "Chunky in Heat." Once-shocking stories such as Harold Brodkey's meditation on a young woman's first orgasm, "Innocence," blaze beside lyrical entries by Michael Chabon, Susan Sontag, Don DeLillo and William Styron. Amy Bloom's "Only You" follows a quirky encounter between a married North Carolina woman and her cross-dressing lover. Pat Califia's "What Girls Are Made Of," from the aptly named collection Melting Point, is a dark and stylish peephole look into the s&m lesbian scene involving women named Poison, Killer and Bo. Other high points include a romantic but realistic excerpt from E.L. Doctorow's Billy Bathgate and a sultry passage from The Mambo Kings Play Songs of Love by Oscar Hijuelos. In their original context, these "good parts" would have climaxed a narrative; here, they produce a rich, sometimes overstimulating effect. Nevertheless, taking into account the current glut of uneven erotica anthologies, this is a refreshing entry: a quality literary collection of beautifully written pieces that happen to be about sex. Not simply titillating, this book's range of voices, eras and settings provides a fascinating and revealing history of how sexuality in America has changed over the last half-century. (Feb.) (c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by Kirkus Book Review
Blair's maiden voyage reprints 47 excerpts from novels and stories in support of the proposition that contemporary literary fiction (most of the selections are from the past ten years) has ``good parts'' as torrid as yesteryear's tawdry paperbacks. The distinguished table of contents'which includes Saul Bellow, Harold Brodkey, Frederick Busch, Don DeLillo, E.L. Doctorow, Mary Gordon, Oscar Hijuelos, Toni Morrison, Joyce Carol Oates, Philip Roth, Jane Smiley, and Susan Sontag'might seem to clinch the case even before page one if erotic titillation weren't so often inversely proportional to more traditional kinds of goodness. Not surprisingly, none of the A-list authors imagines a scene nearly as scorching as the likes of Kathy Acker, Pat Califia, A.M. Homes, Joan Mellen, Dale Peck, Dani Shapiro, and Scott Spencer (though William Styron does his best in a scene from Sophie's Choice). It's certainly true that modern American fiction is a lot more frank in its eroticism than the Victorians' reading matter, and it may well be that explicit sex scenes help fiction achieve more ends than one. Nonetheless, an anthology of spicy scenes, in which erotic psychology is bound to get upstaged at least occasionally by hydraulics, may not be the best place to make that case.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.