Review by Booklist Review
Gr. 5-9. Except for Sook Nyul Choi's Year of Impossible Goodbyes (1991), very little has been written for young people about the Japanese occupation of Korea. Park, who won the Newbery Medal this year for A Single Shard, set in twelfth-century Korea, draws on her parents' experiences as well as extensive historical research for this story. The plot unfolds through the alternating first-person narratives of Sun-hee, who is 10 years old in 1940, and her older brother, Tae-yul. They lose their names and their language when they are forced to use Japanese at school and in public. The far-off war comes closer and hardship increases with brutal neighborhood roundups. Always there are secrets: Who's a traitor? Who's pretending to be a traitor? Sun-hee tries to help her uncle in the resistance, and she's overcome with guilt when she puts him in terrible danger. Tae-yul becomes a kamikaze pilot for the Japanese: he loves learning to fly, but his secret aim is to help the Americans. There's also family conflict, especially about the submissive role of a young girl: does she disobey her father for the good of her country? Why doesn't her father resist? The two young voices sound very much the same, and the historical background sometimes takes over the narrative. The drama is in the facts about the war, and Park does a fine job of showing how the politics of the occupation and resistance affect ordinary people. Be sure to check out Park's Writers and Readers column, "Staying on Past Canal Street: Reflections on Asian Identity," [BKL Ja 1 & 15 02]. --Hazel Rochman
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
"A brother and sister alternate as narrators in this well-constructed novel, which takes place from 1940-1945 in Japanese-occupied Korea," wrote PW in a starred review. "Through the use of the shifting narrators, Park subtly points up the differences between male and female roles in Korean society and telling details provide a clear picture of the siblings and their world." Ages 10-up. (Jan.) (c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by School Library Journal Review
Gr 6-10-Linda Sue Park's historically and emotionally accurate novel (Clarion, 2002) about Korean life under Japanese domination during World War II helps listeners understand how individuals cope in times of political repression. Sun-hee and Tae-yul, sister and brother, live a middle class life with their father, mother, and uncle. Too young to remember a time when the Japanese were not present and officiating in their homeland, these middle grade children are nonetheless shocked by an edict requiring all Koreans to assume Japanese names. As the war escalates, Sun-hee-now known in public as Keoko-gathers her information about world events mostly by eavesdropping and peppering her slightly older brother with questions. Tae-yul eventually leaves home to join the Japanese forces, and his family believes that he met his death on a kamikaze mission. Since chapters alternate between Sun-hee and Tae-yul's memories, readers know that Tae-yul is probably still alive. Jenny Ikeda reads Sun-hee's chapters while Norm Lee performs Tae-yul's. Lee offers more voicing than does Ikeda, and his Tae-yul sounds youthful, while Sun-hee's timber remains that of an adult. This is an excellent addition to middle school collections, offering an angle that has long been missing from the literary shelf.-Francisca Goldsmith, Berkeley Public Library, CA(c) Copyright 2010. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted. All rights reserved.
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Horn Book Review
(Intermediate, Middle School) The author of this year's Newbery winner turns her attention to a different time period in Korean history. In alternating chapters covering the years 1940 to 1945, young siblings Sun-hee and Tae-yul describe their lives during the Japanese military occupation. Tae-yul admires their uncle, who works for the resistance movement printing an underground newspaper; like Uncle, Tae-yul prefers to take action, and by 1945 the eighteen-year-old finds himself in the thick of things. Younger sister Sun-hee is more like their father, subdued and introspective, rebelling against the occupation in quiet but significant ways. The book's title-a poignant reference to the law that forced Koreans to take Japanese names (Sun-hee becomes Keoko and Tae-yul, Nobuo)-seems an inappropriate choice, as it fails to acknowledge the book's effective use of two narrators. The boy/girl narratives widen the audience, of course, but the structure also allows readers to see events from two sometimes-opposing points of view and to witness two different but equally honorable paths of resistance. While the novel's climax is more manipulative than it is believable, readers caught up in the story won't mind all that much. Not as powerful an account as Yoko Kawashima Watkins's So Far from the Bamboo Grove (rev. 7/86) or Sook Nyul Choi's Year of Impossible Goodbyes (rev. 1/92)-but also a less harrowing one that may provide an accessible introduction to this painful history. From HORN BOOK, (c) Copyright 2010. The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
The author of three novels set in different periods of Korean history (A Single Shard, 2001, etc.) now turns to WWII for the story of a brother and sister and their lives with their parents and uncle. Telling their story in alternating voices, the two siblings offer complementary and sometimes different versions of events. Sun-hee, in the last year of elementary school in 1940, loves studying and is an obedient daughter while older brother Tae-yul loves speed and machines. Their uncle is a source of concern because he publishes an underground, anti-Japanese newspaper. The Japanese had conquered Korea in 1910 and as the war looms their demands on the Koreans intensify. Food grows scarcer and the Koreans, long forbidden to study their own culture and language, now must take Japanese names. Thus Sun-hee becomes Keoko. In one memorable passage, Sun-hee misunderstands an oblique warning from her Japanese friend and assumes that her uncle's life is in danger. He flees, never to be seen again as the war and the post-war communist government in the north keep them apart. This beautifully written story captures these events through the eyes of a very likable young girl. In her voice, readers share the joys of playing cat's cradle, eating popcorn, and tasting American chewing gum for the first time. Through Tae-yul's they experience his gritty determination to join a kamikaze unit in order to protect his family from the suspicious Japanese. There is food for thought when Sun-hee's father tells her that "they burn the paper-not the words" when referring to the Japanese soldiers who destroy her diary. There have been relatively few stories for young readers that are set in Asia during WWII. This powerful and riveting tale of one close-knit, proud Korean family movingly addresses life-and-death issues of courage and collaboration, injustice, and death-defying determination in the face of totalitarian oppression. (afterword, bibliography) (Fiction. 10-15)
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.