Review by Booklist Review
K^-Gr. 3. "In a cabin, in a canyon, / Near a mountain laced with pine, / Lived a girl who was my sweetheart, / And her name was Valentine." As Valentine goes about her business, an unnamed admirer tries to send her love notes via homing pigeon, smoke signals (heart-shaped, of course), Morse code, and more--only to have all his letters go astray. Meanwhile, Valentine is busily washing clothes, tidying her cabin, and finally, baking an apple pie, which she carries up a mountainside to hand deliver to the very one who so ardently admires her. Tusa uses sketchy, wispy lines to create loads of droll details that are both funny and subtle (button-eyed Valentine has an enormous pompadour; the homing pigeon is equipped with a little umbrella and a purse), and she tucks delightful clues to the setup ("his" photo on top of the stove) in comic scenes as the climax of the story nears. A parody of "Clementine" is long overdue, and Jackson and Tusa make perfect harmony here--the cadence and rhythm of text and the watercolor artwork are right on pitch in their genuine sweetheart of a book. --Julie Cummins
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
"In a cabin, in a canyon,/ Near a mountain laced with pine,/ Lived a girl who was my sweetheart,/ and her name was Valentine," begins Jackson's (I Know an Old Lady Who Swallowed a Pie) clever adaptation of the familiar folksong "Clementine." Tusa's (Mrs. Spitzer's Garden) sure black line and watercolors add another layer of hilarity to this story-in-song of a resourceful mountain lady and her harried suitor who, through a string of missteps, keep failing to connect. After giving his love letters "to a mailman/ To deliver, rain or shine," Valentine's beau tries more imaginative means, including a homing pigeon that gets sidetracked in Madagascar, and skywriting ("But the wind erased three letters,/ And you're now my -al-n-ine"). Meanwhile, the paintings show the industrious, pointy-nosed object of his affection just missing each message as she tends to frontier chores with a brisk cheeriness. The artist reassuringly establishes from the outset that the feeling is mutual: he keeps a picture of Valentine on his piano; she keeps a cameo of him on her bureau. Attentive readers will detect that the sweethearts' homes are not so far apart, and as the lovestruck fellow misses his target repeatedly, Valentine begins a holiday token of her own affection. It's finally Valentine's personal presentation of her gift that leads to the pair's rendezvous. This inspired treatment of an age-old tale communicates plenty about love. Ages 4-8. (Dec.) (c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by School Library Journal Review
K-Gr 3-A story told in the rhythm of the folk song "My Darling, Clementine." A bashful gentleman sends love messages to his sweetheart, but his proclamations of love never arrive. A homing pigeon flies to Madagascar instead of to Valentine's door with a letter; smoke signals are lost in a cyclone; and a mail car derails, "leaving letters strewn behind." The pages alternate in perspective, portraying the prolific, poetic fellow as well as the plucky lass who goes about her chores and even has time to bake a pie for a special someone. At the end of the book, even though she never receives his messages, Valentine travels from her home across a canyon to deliver her luscious-looking treat to him. Jackson has created a lovesick fellow who, despite his best intentions and for reasons out of his control, just can't seem to do anything right. Valentine is a strong character and readers will feel that her darling will be safe as long as she's with him. Tusa's quirky watercolor illustrations portray a simpler time, when folks communicated by Morse code, an airplane was a modest machine, and a homemade apple pie signified true love and devotion. Without ever being treacly or melodramatic, this fun book is ideal for Valentine's Day programs.-Shawn Brommer, South Central Library System, Madison, WI (c) Copyright 2010. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
Clever interplay of text and art makes this ballad more than a simple love story. The text (which can be sung to the tune of "Clementine") tells the tale of a heartsick man who is hilariously stymied in his repeated efforts to declare his love to his neighbor Valentine: the postman can't find her address, the homing pigeon gets lost in Madagascar, a cyclone blows away smoke signals, and so on. Illustrations of her besotted admirer's attempts to get his message across are interspersed with images of Valentine going about her business. They reveal that canny Valentine may have figured out what's going on; in a hint of things to come, she's shown on the cover carrying a basket of apples, internal illustrations show her milking, mixing ingredients, baking a pie, and climbing over hill and dale to deliver the sweet, freshly baked treat to her frustrated, exhausted suitor, making for a happy ending. Comical depictions of the smitten man's attempts to get his message across are suitably exaggerated; Valentine herself sports a beatific smile and huge upswept hairdo along with her traditional apron and flowered dress as she does her chores and bakes for her sweetie. Just right for Valentine's Day, this is funny and satisfying without being too sugary. (Picture book. 4-8)
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
