Review by Choice Review
This is a chilling account of the development of the pseudoscience of eugenics and its ultimate effects. Black (IBM and the Holocaust, 2001) begins with the earliest work in the subject, begun by British researcher Francis Galton, who coined the term "eugenics" and who pushed ideas that encouraged human individuals with strong positive genetic traits to reproduce ("positive eugenics"). Americans interested in improving the human race accepted Galton's ideas, but they developed a far different approach--that of "negative eugenics," by which they hoped to identify and sterilize, by force if necessary, those people who were "defective," according to their standards. Eugenics acquired prominent US supporters, including Mrs. E.H. Harriman and the Carnegie and Rockefeller foundations. Black argues convincingly that US eugenicists inspired German researchers, who were able to apply negative eugenic principles with the enthusiastic support of the Nazi government. This book carries an important message about the use and misuse of scientific and social research. That message is especially important in an age when the term "genetic engineering" is heard frequently. Buy this book. Put it on your shelves. Urge your patrons to read and ponder its contents. ^BSumming Up: Essential. All libraries. J. P. Sanson Louisiana State University at Alexandria
Copyright American Library Association, used with permission.
Review by Booklist Review
Read all of his new book, investigative reporter Black insists, or none of it. Good advice, despite Black's many repetitions, odd word choices, and grammatical gaffes, for the story he tells shouldn't be imperfectly known. Its crux is that American researchers and laws inspired Nazi racism. Building on nineteenth-century English statistician Francis Galton's speculations about human heredity, and calling their highly subjective work eugenics, early-twentieth-century American researcher-activists persuaded many states to permit sexual sterilization of the mentally and physically inferior. With American eugenists cheering them on, the Nazis advanced to exterminating those deemed inferior. Thoroughly chronicling eugenics in America and Germany, Black stresses what happened rather than why. He doesn't probe individual eugenists' deep motivations or hazard cultural explanations; indeed, after exposing Planned Parenthood founder Margaret Sanger's lifelong adherence to eugenics, Black pronounces her a great humanitarian. Less timorously, he asks whether contemporary genetics is becoming "newgenics" as insurance companies and employers find reasons to create an uninsurable, unemployable genetic underclass. Turgid but impressive, probably the popular history of eugenics for the foreseeable future. --Ray Olson Copyright 2003 Booklist
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
In the first half of the 20th century, more than 60,000 Americans-poor, uneducated, members of minorities-were forcibly sterilized to prevent them from passing on supposedly defective genes. This policy, called eugenics, was the brainchild of such influential people as Rockefellers, Andrew Carnegie and Margaret Sanger. Black, author of the bestselling IBM and the Holocaust, set out to show "the sad truth of how the scientific rationales that drove killer doctors at Auschwitz were first concocted on Long Island" at the Carnegie Institution's Cold Spring Harbor complex. Along the way, he offers a detailed and heavily footnoted history that traces eugenics from its inception to America's eventual, post-WWII retreat from it, complete with stories of the people behind it, their legal battles, their detractors and the tragic stories of their victims. Black's team of 50 researchers have done an impressive job, and the resulting story is at once shocking and gripping. But the publisher's claim that Black has uncovered the truth behind America's "dirty little secret" is a bit overstated. There is a growing library of books on eugenics, including Daniel Kevles's In the Name of Eugenics and Ellen Chesler's biography of Margaret Sanger, Woman of Valor. Black's writing tends to fluctuate from scholarly to melodramatic and apocalyptic (and sometimes arrogant), but the end result is an important book that will add to the public's understanding of this critical chapter of American history. (Sept. 7) Forecast: The publisher is supporting this in a big way, with a 75,000 first printing, a $100,000 marketing budget and a 20-city author tour. Given the success of IBM and the Holocaust, this stands to get media attention and excellent sales. (c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by Library Journal Review
That there existed an organized eugenics movement in America during the early 20th century is one of this country's dirty little secrets. In this bombshell of investigative journalism, Black (IBM and the Holocaust) reveals that it was extensive, systematic, well funded, and supported by major political and intellectual leaders; perhaps most startling, it directly inspired the rise of Nazism in Hitler's Germany. In America, the doctrine of eugenics was justified by pseudoscientific ideologies of social Darwinism and aimed, ultimately, to improve the human race by culling inferior lineages from the gene pool. The primary tool was forced sterilization of those deemed "feeble-minded." In practice, it became a legal and purportedly high-minded means by which to conduct racial and class warfare-the very features that made it appealing to the Nazis. It took the horrors of the Holocaust to discredit eugenics, but, as Black cautions, with governments today creating DNA banks of their citizens and groups from law enforcement to insurance companies seeking access to these banks, there is a reborn threat. This chilling and well-researched book is highly recommended.-Gregg Sapp, Science Lib., SUNY at Albany (c) Copyright 2010. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
A journalistic exposÉ of the early-20th-century American eugenics movement and its application in the death camps of the Third Reich. By Black's (IBM and the Holocaust, not reviewed) account, the various American eugenicists who brought crop- and livestock-breeding techniques to the business of creating perfect humans were masters of scientific fraud, working with the blessing and material support of major corporations and foundations in the interest of "racism, ethnic hatred and academic elitism." Though predicated on overstatement--many such scientists, then as now, were looking to eradicate categories of disease, not of people--Black's case has many merits: plenty of practitioners, working through hospitals and laboratories meant to stamp out the "feebleminded" and crippled and even those unfortunates with bad vision, had in mind the creation of a Nordic European "super race enjoying biological dominion over all others." The eugenics program put in practice throughout the US, but with particular zeal in Virginia and California, targeted victims of disease, to be sure, but also the poor and members of ethnic minorities, especially blacks and Native Americans. That program met with some resistance among scientists and social engineers, who complained that such things as tuberculosis and violent crime alike were the products of poverty and not heredity; but it also enjoyed strong support among political leaders, including Woodrow Wilson and Oliver Wendell Holmes. Along the way, Adolf Hitler became enamored of American experiments to rid the nation of the genetically suspect, and American eugenicists did a land-office business as consultants and lecturers in the Third Reich; soon, as US scientist C.M. Goethe noted, the Germans had sterilized more people in two years than California had in a quarter century. But even after WWII, Black writes, "after the Hitler regime, after the Nuremberg Trials, some twenty thousand Americans were eugenically sterilized by states and untold others by federal programs on Indian reservations and in U.S. territories such as Puerto Rico." Though sure to be contested at points, of interest to human-rights activists monitoring the doings of bioengineers--who are just eugenicists, Black argues, under another name. Copyright ©Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
