Review by Booklist Review
In a departure from McKinley's prior work, which includes high fantasies like her Newbery Medal book, The Hero and the Crown (1984), this novel's contemporary U.S. setting feels like a curveball. Soon enough, though, McKinley reveals a distinctly fantastical aspect of the nature preserve run by the father of narrator Jake: it's devoted to Draco australiensis, among the last of the world's elusive dragons. Jake, an aspiring scientist himself, dangerously challenges presiding theories about how humans and dragons ought to relate when he secretly (and illegally) raises an orphaned dragonlet. McKinley offers a compelling premise, portraying the demands and rewards of Jake's foster-parenting with particular clarity; however, the central plotlines frequently feel lost in the tangled digressions of Jake's stream-of-consciousness narrative. Offer this to teens interested in environmental issues and animal ethics, who will admire its offbeat eco-adventure angle, and to patient, thoughtful YAs, who will side with passionate Jake for both his capable intelligence and his willingness to entertain world-detonating new ideas.--Mattson, Jennifer Copyright 2007 Booklist
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
Set in a world nearly identical to our own-except for the existence of Draco australiensis (gigantic, reclusive, fire-breathing dragons who raise their infants in marsupial-like pouches)-this big, ambitious novel marks a departure of sorts for Newbery Medalist McKinley, whose previous works take place either in the realm of fairy tale and legend (Spindle's End) or the magical land of Damar (The Hero and the Crown). But fans will instantly recognize its protagonist, the tightly wound and solitary Jake, as classic McKinley. On his first-ever solo expedition in remotest Smokehill (the Wyoming dragon preserve and national park where he was raised), Jake stumbles across the single surviving newborn of a female dragon slaughtered by a poacher. Jake takes on the challenge of raising the orphaned creature, describing the process in minute and loving detail ("She was hopeless as a lapdog-the wrong shape, and she was too thick-bodied to curl properly-but she'd lie pretty contentedly on my bare feet, or behind my ankles-that's when she was willing... to lie down at all. She went on wanting skin [contact], and she still spent nights lying against my stomach"). When Jake attempts to reintroduce the dragon to her own species, a brave new era of dragon-human relations begins. One quibble: because Jake tells the story as a memoir, some climactic moments tend to be relayed at arm's length. On balance, McKinley renders her imagined universe so potently that readers will wish they could book their next vacation in Smokehill. Ages 12-up. (Sept.) (c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by School Library Journal Review
Gr 5-9-Fifteen-year-old Jake lives on a dragon preserve, the Makepeace Institute of Integrated Dragon Studies, in Smokehill National Park in Wyoming. About 200 dragons live there. When Jake's dad allows him to go on his first solo overnight trip, no one could ever imagine the peril he would encounter. A dying mother dragon, a baby dragon hatchling, and a dead poacher forever change life at the preserve. No human has ever spent time around a baby dragon because of a law forbidding the aiding of a dragon's survival. Keeping the baby a secret is easier said than done, especially when tourists are trying to break into the preserve and the federal government is investigating the poacher's death. Will the preserve and the baby dragon survive? How did the poacher get in? Does Smokehill have a security problem? Although this book has a relatively slow pace, Noah Galvin injects liveliness to this unique tale with his expressive narrative style and voices. For fans of fantasy, adventure, and mystery.-Jessica Moody, Olympus Jr. High, Holladay, UT (c) Copyright 2012. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Horn Book Review
(Middle School, High School) Jake has grown up at Makepeace Institute of Integrated Dragon Studies in a national park dedicated to the preservation of dragons. On his first solo overnight hike, he witnesses the death of a mother dragon and becomes surrogate mother to her only surviving baby. What Jake learns from Lois (as he names the baby dragon) transforms dragon studies; at the same time, the Institute fights for its life, the prime target of a powerful new anti-dragon movement. McKinley sets herself two difficult tasks here: first, her narrator is verbose and full of himself; secondly, the boy-and-animal story is only marginally interested in humans, contains little dialogue or suspense, and is excruciatingly slow. Both elements may try readers' patience, but for the persevering, Dragonhaven has its rewards. In her customary way McKinley evokes a complete, detailed alternate reality; her affection for animal life is patent in her extensive descriptions of the developmental stages, language, and social habits of dragons. Jake often sounds self-conscious and superior and has an annoying penchant for parenthetical interruption, but even this is part of the convincing fiction of a boy from an insulated but intelligent world. (c) Copyright 2010. The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted. All rights reserved.
(c) Copyright The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
A sharply incisive, wildly intelligent dragon fantasy involving profound layers of science and society, love and loss and nature and nurture. Jake's lived his whole life in Smokehill National Park, federally protected land that harbors much of the world's dwindling dragon population. His father runs the Institute there, but even the most dedicated scientists rarely see dragons, who stay far away from the touristy, human-populated area. On an overnight solo, Jake finds a mother dragon dying, with tiny blobs--barely identifiable dragonlets--on the ground next to her. Jake desperately sticks the single live dragonlet down his shirt, beginning a momentous, multi-year task with worldwide implications. While harming a dragon is illegal, saving one is equally punishable. In McKinley's realistic America, science and law are heavily influenced by funding and public opinion. Despite Jake's constant anxiety and confusion over the years, every day fraught with secrecy and the fear of harming his dragonlet, his tight narration is penetratingly insightful about emotion, biology, language and the intricate love/hate relationship between science and humanity. Quietly magnificent. (Fantasy. YA) Copyright ©Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
