Review by Booklist Review
Students for a Democratic Society (SDS) was the most disturbing radical aggregation of the 1960s, for it attracted plenty of solid citizens' collegiate children rather than, like the civil rights movement, primarily young blacks and Jews. Pekar and colleagues scant that aspect of their subject to sketch the history of the national organization and, in the three-times-longer second part of the book, let former members speak, often about their local SDS chapters, whose activities could sharply diverge from the agenda of the national office. The violent Weathermen Underground emerged from the dissolution of the national SDS and has overshadowed its parent in the public memory, but it seems from the individual testimonies here that grassroots community organizing in cities including Chicago and Cleveland may be SDS' most important legacy. Oddly enough, considering that the older half of the baby boomers, at least, grew up with SDS, scholarly popular histories of it are rare. This comics treatment isn't enough, especially when drawn this drably, but it'll have to do for now.--Olson, Ray Copyright 2007 Booklist
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
American Splendor's Pekar has been incredibly prolific in the last few years, and more recently he has taken on nonautobiographical projects to varying degrees of success. This newest effort works on a variety of levels. For one, Pekar is not the sole author. He constructs a narrative of the history of the Students for a Democratic Society, but frequently steps aside to allow actual participants in that history to tell their own stories, using his casual first-person model of storytelling. The narrative moves through the decade of SDS history and then moves into the participant accounts, offering both a macro and a micro vision of the times. The artwork is mostly by frequent Pekar collaborator Gary Dumm, whose crisp, neutral realism may not be thrilling but does move the story along and does a fine job of conveying the various settings. As a whole, the book acts like a sophisticated handbook on an often misunderstood organization. It's good comics and excellent history. (Jan.) (c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by School Library Journal Review
Gr 10 Up-Among the organizations agitating for social change in the 1960s, Students for a Democratic Society concentrated its efforts on young people. This graphic history uses black-and-white art to effectively document the group's history, from its founding to its split and eventual end. The first section recounts the origins of SDS in great detail and profiles early leaders. However, it would have been strengthened by inclusion of the Port Huron Statement, mentioned several times. A glossary or explanation of some political terms and introduction of prominent activists of the time is also lacking. Recollections of SDS programs, actions, and initiatives in the second section illustrate the range of activities in which individual members participated. Remembered most for spearheading the anti-Vietnam War movement on college campuses, SDS also promoted community outreach. Independent chapters sent members to Kentucky in support of a miners' strike and into neighborhoods around urban campuses to help tenants fight university takeovers of their buildings. Several women trace the beginnings of what became the women's liberation movement to their involvement in SDS. Students looking for background and details of the tumultuous social changes that happened in the 1960s will find plenty to satisfy them here.-Ellie Goldstein-Erickson, Berkeley High School Library, CA (c) Copyright 2010. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
The story of the legendary 1960s student-activist group, in words and pictures. With the acceptance of graphic novels and nonfiction into the mainstream, Pekar (Macedonia, 2007, etc.) seems to have more work than ever--you can almost hear his curmudgeonly grumbling about deadlines--and he has branched out beyond the autobiographical writings showcased in issues of American Splendor. As witness this graphic history of Students for a Democratic Society (SDS): written mostly by Pekar, supplemented by several former SDS members; edited by Buhle, founding editor of the SDS journal Radical America, who also wrote several sections; with effective art by frequent Splendor collaborator Dumm. Although he's never been shy about his angry leftist political leanings or about shoving himself into a narrative, Pekar keeps almost entirely in the background here as the book parses the minutiae of SDS's creation, rise to prominence, post-Nixon splintering and, very briefly, its resurgence in 2006. Founded in 1960 as an offshoot of various lefty-labor organizations that traced their lineage back to Upton Sinclair in 1905, SDS quickly alienated more staid elements of the Old Left with its emphasis on personal freedom, solidarity with the civil-rights movement and vehement antiwar stance. Throughout the mid and late '60s, SDS grew in numbers, leading demonstrations and publishing agitprop journals in cities and campuses across the nation, while it was simultaneously riven from within by agent provocateurs and fractious infighting among factions like the Weathermen and doctrinaire Marxists. Eschewing a standard time line, many of the book's later pages offer journal-like contributions from rank-and-file members, who provide snapshots of the life-altering struggle they were engaged in--often with a self-deprecating nod to its more na™ve aspects. Learned, passionate and accessible history of the first order, casting a critical but mostly benevolent eye on an often-contradictory movement. Copyright ©Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
