Review by Choice Review
This is the first modern edition of a Charlotte Bronte novel that is based on the author's original manuscript. The useful introduction explains the history of this novel's composition and publication. Its appendixes include an unused Bronte preface, a list of editorial variants, and several related manuscripts. Additionally, there is an index to the literary and biblical allusions in all four of Charlotte Bronte's major novels. This important Clarendon edition is essential for all serious collections in Victorian fiction serving graduate students and upper-division undergraduates. -S. A. Parker, Hiram College
Copyright American Library Association, used with permission.
Review by Library Journal Review
This first novel went unpublished during Bront?'s lifetime, rejected by publishers each time it was submitted despite her growing fame for such works as Jane Eyre and Shirley. It was released only after her untimely passing, when there was a great hunger for anything from the pen of this now-famous author, but it was a poor addition to her work. A critic in 1857 wrote that it was "crude, unequal, and unnatural to a fault; it has all the unripe qualities of a bad first work." And indeed it is dreary and confusing, uninvolving and filled with minutiae, and suffers from many awkward and improbable devices, not the least of which is the choice of a male protagonist to tell a tale with many autobiographical aspects. The reading by James Wilby is expert and probably as exciting and dramatic as is possible, given the material. Comprehensive literary collections will want to add this early work of a major author, but more popular collections can safely pass it by.AHarriet Edwards, East Meadow P.L., NY (c) Copyright 2010. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.