Review by Choice Review
The birth of modern science is most often associated with the scientists of the Enlightenment. Many historians have claimed that the advances in thinking made by the leading thinkers of the Enlightenment were a result of the contributions of Renaissance scholars. Freely (Bosphorous Univ., Turkey), a prolific author (e.g., Light from the East, CH, Nov'11, 49-1423; The Grand Turk, CH, Aug'10, 47-7040), makes a remarkable claim that situates the origins of modern science in medieval Europe. He builds the framework for this book on published primary sources and a small set of secondary sources. The author traces a decline in Western science to the fall of the Roman Empire and the destruction of the ancient library of Alexandria. Freely expertly traces the connections between the ancient scientific world and the medieval period by demonstrating the importance of teacher-to-student knowledge dissemination. Unfortunately, it is difficult to follow his narrative, and there is no discernible engagement with the historiographical literature to give the reader contextual understanding of these complex historical processes and events. Nevertheless, this is a fascinating work written by an exceptional scholar, offering a challenge for scholars to revisit classic questions in the historiography. Summing Up: Recommended. Lower-division undergraduates through researchers/faculty; general readers. G. D. Oberle III Germanna Community College
Copyright American Library Association, used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
Freely makes the surprising case for modern science's origins during the Dark Ages, centuries before Galileo and the scientific revolution. With the destruction of the Library of Alexandria in 48 B.C.E., original works from Homer, Plato, Aristotle, Euclid, and others were lost to the Western world. Fortunately, some secondhand copies and other fragments survived in the possession of scholars outside Alexandria; preserved in monasteries across western Europe, the materials also excited further study when, after 762 C.E., they reached the Arab world of the Abbasid caliphate. Freely explains how, despite the opinion of many medieval Christian scholars that the study of science was unnecessary-"for in order to save one's soul, it is enough to believe in God"-translations into Latin by clergymen-scholars like Boethius, Cassiodorus, and Gerard of Cremona disseminated ancient Greek and more contemporary Arab ideas, heavily influencing medieval thinkers. Thus, reintroduction of Aristotle's cause-and-effect reasoning forced scholars like Thomas Aquinas to walk "a tightrope to avoid conflict with Church dogma," but from Bologna to Oxford secular universities began to flourish, nourishing the roots of what became Roger Bacon's "scientific method" and Copernicus's heliocentric solar system. Freely's argument isn't entirely convincing, but he does provide a detailed look at the lineage and transmission of scientific thought from the Greeks through the medieval era. Agent: Derek Johns, AP Watt Ltd. (U.K.). (Oct.) (c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved.
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by Library Journal Review
Freely (physics, Bosphorous Univ., Istanbul; Aladdin's Lamp: How Greek Science Came to Europe Through the Islamic World) writes here of the people who sought explanations of happenings in the natural world, as well as the works they wrote about what they found, from roughly 400 BCE to CE 1700. He charts the path of scientific movements among cultures (primarily Christian Europe and the Muslim Mediterranean and Middle East) depending on extant information of historical events and individuals, and the translations thereof. Earlier works on this topic have less breadth, as one would expect, because fewer works survived. However, readers will appreciate Freely's comprehensiveness, particularly when he reaches later periods (e.g., around 1000 CE). Among the small but significant events Freely discusses is how something as relatively simple as understanding and explaining the shape, angle, and colors of rainbows could prompt European science to leap radically forward. VERDICT Recommended for readers who enjoy the history of science.-Michael D. Cramer, Schwarz BioSciences, Research Triangle Park, NC (c) Copyright 2012. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
A history of science in the centuries before Copernicus, Galileo and Newton. After the Visigoth sack of Rome in 410 and the subsequent burning of the great Library of Alexandria, the ancient Greco-Roman world descended into the darkness of the early Middle Ages, writes historian Freely (Physics/Bosphorous Univ.; Light From the East: How the Science of Medieval Islam Helped to Shape the Western World, 2011, etc.). Yet fragments of classical learning survived in the keeping of a handful of scholars in monasteries. In time, the monastic movement produced the first European scientists, whose work sparked the emergence of modern science. In this revealing but plodding account, Freely traces the transmission of ancient Greek philosophical and scientific works to the Islamic world, where scholars took the lead in science and passed their knowledge on to Europe. In thumbnail portraits, he describes the work of Ibn Sina, Gerard of Cremona and others who conveyed Arab science to the West. By 1500, Europe, with 80 universities, had undergone "a tremendous intellectual revival." Freely charts the advance of that revival, with Albertus Magnus becoming the first to use the modern scientific method based on observation and experimentation, and Robert Grosseteste and Roger Bacon making full use of the experimental method. In an overview of subsequent, increasingly modern science, Freely describes work on the new science of motion by 14th-century Oxford scientists; Newton's successful explanation of the rainbow in 1714; and the astronomical observations and calculations of Copernicus, which marked the onset of the scientific revolution. For specialists and students.]] Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
