Review by Booklist Review
A stray gray cat stows away in a family's luggage for the European vacation of a lifetime. Our feline tour guide follows the family by way of truck, train, and boat, from Italy to France to England and so on. While Banks' rhyming verse doesn't often pin down City Cat's exact location City Cat scales ragged walls. / She romps through ruins set in stone. / Then tiptoes through a sacred space / and cuddles in a hidden place Castillo's soft drawings set the scene in great detail (the one just described, for instance, puts us at Rome's Colosseum). The renderings of place are meticulous, and the cat moves quietly and subtly from location to location. Parents will have fun pointing out identifying details, like a French flag waving in the wind, while little kids will enjoy admiring the cityscapes and finding the surreptitious feline on each spread. Back matter includes a map charting the cat's route and offers up further information on each of the sites visited. Pair with Caroline Lazo's Someday When My Cat Can Talk (2008) for more kitty-does-Europe sightseeing adventures.--Kelley, Ann Copyright 2010 Booklist
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
Banks's verse sees some of the great cities of Europe through the travels of an independent black cat. Making her way by cat, boat, bike, and bus, City Cat romps through the Coliseum, nestles under one of Notre Dame's gargoyles, and pads across the Bridge of Sighs. The scenery described isn't pinned to a specific location: "City Cat is on the run from the morning mist/ and the baffled sun hidden by the fog./ She squints into a smoky sky/ and sees a tower rising high." It's up to Castillo, who illustrated Banks's That's Papa's Way, to supply the missing information, drawing what's visible in the fog: Big Ben and the Houses of Parliament. In the absence of a character to know more deeply or a narrative to tie the book together, the meticulously drawn spreads take center stage. Castillo takes no shortcuts, drafting each city's distinctive architecture in soft, pleasing lines. Though there are parallels with Banks's The Cat Who Walked Across France, this feline isn't trying to get home; she's happy to wander Europe's plazas and cathedral squares, and to have readers trail along. Ages 3-7. Illustrator's agent: Paul Rodeen, Rodeen Literary Management. (Nov.) (c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved.
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by School Library Journal Review
PreS-K-City Cat travels through Europe, paralleling a human family's vacation. Rhyming verse follows the stray as she hitches rides and wanders through Italy, France, Spain, England, the Netherlands, and Germany. Flags dot the various spreads, giving clues to the locations, which are further described in the endnotes. Lyrical verse follows an interesting rhyming scheme and incorporates rich vocabulary, and lush illustrations capture the atmosphere of each location with plenty of details to invite close study. Children will enjoy the fanciful adventures of this intrepid feline as she explores rooftops, bridges, and ancient ruins, especially when compared to the rather boring, grounded meanderings of the human tourists. However, not much happens in the story and the connection between the cat and the family is not clear. Overall, this is a pretty book for armchair travelers and cat lovers.-Suzanne Myers Harold, formerly at Multnomah County Library System, Portland, OR (c) Copyright 2013. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Horn Book Review
A small smoky-gray cat follows a family on its trip through Europe. She hitches rides, stows away on boats, cadges food, and invites herself behind the scenes. As is the way of cats, she makes herself supremely comfortable wherever she is, whether bathing in a Parisian fountain or picking her way across the roof of Gaudi's Casa Batllo in Barcelona. Castillo's drawings capture both the grandeur of great cities and their human dynamism as people cycle, shop, work, rush, parade, dress up, and even play the tuba. In each picture, we look for the family, and the family looks for the cat. Banks's text is confident and rhythmic, dotted with rhymes and half-rhymes that bounce off the tongue. "She sits on piers with perked-up ears / and gazes out to sea." The words pass the read-it-again test with flying colors. A well-traveled child, armchair or otherwise, will spot Big Ben and the Eiffel Tower. For all the rest, an appended spread, both child- and cat-oriented, identifies the cities and the sights, and a map lets us trace the family's eight-city journey. sarah ellis (c) Copyright 2014. The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
A black cat serves as European tour guide for child readers in this offering from Banks and Castillo. The cat and a family of travelers begin in Rome. Outstanding backmatter later tells readers that the famed Coliseum is home to over 200 stray cats that are protected by Roman law. But before reaching the informational paratext, readers follow the cat from one European locale to another, right alongside the family on holiday. The family seems almost superfluous, even intrusive to the cat's adventure. First, the cat stows away in the back of the family's car and ends up in Marseille, and it then goes on to Barcelona and five other destinations before returning to Rome. Banks' graceful writing describes the sites visited through sensory detail, while Castillo's soft, yet detailed art deftly fills in narrative gaps by showing how the cat gets from place to place. Some legs of the journey may seem a bit implausible, and it's quite coincidental that the cat and the family keep turning up in the same places. By book's end, the nod to the child asleep in his bed and the cat "curled up in a statue's arm" nearby feels rather forced. Nevertheless, the art presents a veritable feast for the eyes from page to page, and Banks' narrative is characteristically well-paced and lyrical. A lovely, if unlikely, feline journey. (Picture book. 4-8)]] Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
