Review by Choice Review
Kitcher (Columbia Univ.) successfully avoids repeating the attacks on religion made by "new atheists," which focus on showing flaws in the least sophisticated senses of religion. Instead, Kitcher thoughtfully develops his case for secular humanism by disclosing how it offers consistent answers to human questions--even those important questions (meaningfulness and ethics) that religion is developed to address. Oriented by an analytical philosophy of religion approach, Kitcher remains respectful of the human motivations for religious belief even while articulating the doubts that drive the project of secularism. The book's tone is conversational, with reference to both thought experiments and classic literary texts that flesh out Kitcher's frequent references to William James. The book's analytical approach to religion attends to its practical functions in human lives at the expense of exploring more robust theological explanations for the value of religion, contrasting with Paul Tillich's Terry Lectures, published as The Courage to Be (now in its third edition; 2014), which Kitcher mentions in passing. Life after Faith provides readers with an educated view of the possibilities and limitations of secular humanism, relative to a respectful but distanced view of religion. Summing Up: Recommended. Lower-level undergraduates and above; general readers. --Daniel R. Boscaljon, independent scholar
Copyright American Library Association, used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
Yale's annual Terry Lectures have yielded another elegant book that addresses contemporary concerns. Kitcher's well-organized presentation ranges widely in drawing together sources from literature, philosophy, and the sciences to respectfully make a persuasive case that a secular outlook on life can produce value, meaning, and solace, all functions that religion has traditionally filled. He reasons sans broadsides, finding that religion is not so much violent or evilâ_"as many of today's atheists argueâ_"as it is improbable and, more important, unnecessary. He is a kind critic of religion, conceding that "refined religion," the highest form of belief and practice, has at least the advantage of being better organized to act for human improvement, since there are as yet no numerous or vast bodies of secular humanists doing disaster relief. (Give it time, he suggests.) Kitcher's real strength is his sensitivity to human suffering and mortality, and the ways in which those concerns must be addressed by a robust secular ethic. (Oct.) © Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved.
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by Library Journal Review
The subtitle of this collection of Kitcher's (John Dewey Professor of Philosophy, Columbia Univ.; Preludes to Pragmatism) Terry Lectures forms the aim of this project, an articulation and defense of a secular humanism that is broader than militant atheism. One can divide Kitcher's strategy into two parts. First he separates religion into two types-unrefined and refined. The former involves a literal adherence to the tenets of a religion (which he quickly dispatches as fiction), while the latter relies on symbol and metaphor to point to an otherwise ineffable transcendent. This procedure has the curious effect of placing such sophisticated theists as Marilyn McCord Adams and Peter van Inwagen in the unrefined camp, but Kitcher's focus is on refined religion. Here again the case is two-fold: one argues for the ineffectualness of the transcendent in establishing reasonable judgments, and the other is a series of statements that secular humanism can provide a basis for those things that religion (broadly conceived) has long been seen as a bulwark-ethics, values, and meaning. While tightly reasoned, this set of lectures is also lively and engaging. VERDICT This title makes for a fine touchstone for those interested in the discussion of the function of religion in a secular society.-James Wetherbee, Wingate Univ. Libs., NC (c) Copyright 2014. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
