Review by New York Times Review
AUTISM HAS COME of age, rapidly growing into a matter of common knowledge. Who doesn't now know that this condition is framed by a wide spectrum, or that diagnosed cases continue to rise? With one in 68 children affected, tens of millions in the United States know someone, or of someone, on the spectrum. Those who don't can watch Sheldon's autistic-like behaviors on CBS's "The Big Bang Theory." What might be called "autism lit" has evolved, as well, with novels and nonfiction showcasing autism's piquant and painful weave of deep weaknesses and subtle, splintered strengths. Now, Ann M. Martin, a Newbery Honor winner, offers this affecting, elegantly burnished middle-grade book about a girl with autism. Though I'm not sure age subcategories are pertinent. If you can read, you'll love this book. The narrator, a fifth grader named Rose, has a passion for the homonym - a word that sounds just like another word (it's right there in the rather clunky title). She lives in upstate New York with her volatile, intermittently employed father, has a kind uncle who drives her to school, and loves that "the word 'pair' implies two but is part of a homonym trio - pair, pear and pare." The plot takes off as Rose's father says they can keep a collarless dog he found in a downpour. A rule-follower like many kids on the spectrum, Rose asks if they should look for the owners; her father responds, "If they didn't care enough to get her a collar then they don't deserve her." When Rose asks if the dog is "a gift" her father answers: "Yes, she's a gift, Rose. She's my gift to you." The child never gets gifts from her often drunken father, who has cared for her in dispiriting penury since her mother left them long ago. Father and daughter, of course, are strays as well, and what unfolds is a kind of modern-day fable, dealing with some of the thorniest problems that cripple society and those who live on its well-worn edges. The damp, shaking animal, whom Rose names Rain, blossoms under her loving care, becoming the face-licking soul mate to a child who has not a single friend. She's lonely but unable to connect with peers - a tough, underrecognized truth for many kids on the autism spectrum. The deftness with which Martin renders Rose's life is admirable - from the special-needs aide who sits by her side in class and pulls her into the hall for timeouts, to the classmates who manage only glancing, often comical interactions with the math whiz who blurts out rules (when others break them) and recites prime numbers to restore her balance. And yet the book isn't actually about autism, or even any coming-of-age theme. It's about love and fealty, fear, hope, the release from burdens, and what kids - all kids - need but often don't get. As in all the best fiction, Martin's plot throws the reader into confusion right beside the characters. Just try this one out: As the father turns frighteningly angry and Rose holds on to her only companion, Rain, for dear life, the child discovers that many dogs carry a microchip in case they run off without their collar. Does our 11-year-old rule-follower try to return the dog and give up her only joy; or does she hold tight to this furry somebody dropped in her lap by a world that has denied her almost everything? Read and find out, but don't take this book anywhere you wouldn't want to have a sudden burst of tears. Or, for that matter, a wash of warm recognition that we all - the poor and neurologically challenged, too - can find a way to the sunlight. RON SUSKIND, the author of "Life, Animated: A Story of Sidekicks, Heroes and Autism," directs Harvard's Project on Public Narrative.
Copyright (c) The New York Times Company [November 2, 2014]
Review by Booklist Review
*Starred Review* Rose, a fifth-grader who has been diagnosed with Asperger syndrome, is often teased at school about her obsession with homonyms and her steadfast conviction that everyone should follow the rules at all times. Rose lives with her harsh, troubled father, but it's Uncle Weldon who cares for her in the ways that matter most. Still, her father did give her Rain, a stray dog that comforts and protects Rose. After Rain is lost in a storm and recovered, Rose learns that her dog has an identification microchip. Though she fully grasps what that means, Rose is driven by the unwavering belief that she must follow the rules, find Rain's former owners, and give the dog back to them. Simplicity, clarity, and emotional resonance are hallmarks of Rose's first-person narrative, which offers an unflinching view of her world from her perspective. Her outlook may be unconventional, but her approach is matter-of-fact and her observations are insightful. Readers will be moved by the raw portrayal of Rose's difficult home life, her separation from other kids at school, and her loss of the dog that has loved her and provided a buffer from painful experiences. A strong story told in a nuanced, highly accessible way.--Phelan, Carolyn Copyright 2014 Booklist
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
Starred Review. Rose Howard is a high-functioning autistic fifth-grader, and her preoccupation with homophones, her insistence on rules being followed to the letter of the law, and her difficulties reading social cues and understanding emotions are giving her trouble at school and frustrating her impatient and often angry single father. Rose's own feelings of anxiety and worry are viscerally felt when her dog, Rain, gets lost after a storm wreaks havoc in her small New York town. As Rose's sense of order is disrupted by floods, uprooted trees, and destroyed buildings, she methodically follows a plan to bring Rain home, though things don't go as expected. Newbery Honor author Martin (A Corner of the Universe) is extremely successful in capturing Rose's perspective and personality; Rose can't always recognize when she is being treated unkindly (it's no rare occurrence), but readers will see what she is up against, as well as the efforts of those who reach out to her. Filled with integrity and determination, Rose overcomes significant obstacles in order to do what is right. Ages 9-12. Agent: Amy Berkower, Writers House. (Oct.) (c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved.
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by School Library Journal Review
Gr 4-6-Because she has Asperger's syndrome, Rose Howard is obsessed with homonyms, rules, and order. She has a hard time containing her emotions and a teacher's aid must sit with her during class. Dealing with her condition is difficult for Rose's father, who is raising her alone, but thanks to her dog, Rain, a caring uncle, and a new friend, Rose may just find the strength to be her very best self. Laura Hamilton takes on the challenging role of Rose without missing a beat. She puts just the right pauses in her speech as she struggles to make herself understood and takes on a slightly robotic tone each time Rose comes across a homonym and must carefully repeat each of the words. Her matter-of-fact yet youthful tone is perfect, and her use of pitch emphasizes each time Rose becomes upset or frustrated. Hamilton also is able to expertly use a lower range for Rose's emotionally distant father and her uncle. VERDICT This is an ideal family listen about the power of family and the bond between a girl and her dog.-Shari Fesko, Southfield Public Library, MI (c) Copyright 2015. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Horn Book Review
Eleven-year-old Rose's "official diagnosis is high-functioning autism." She lives with her single dad, who does not have the resources, material or emotional, to be a parent. At school she is laughed at by her classmates. Her life works, but just barely. Uncle Weldon has her back; she is soothed by her ongoing collection of homonyms; and, best of all, she has Rain, her dog. This fragile contentment is shattered by Hurricane Susan, during which Rain disappears. A bad dad, a missing dog--this could be a tearjerker. It isn't. Rose is a character we root for every step of the way. She is resilient, honest, and, in her own odd way, very perceptive; a most reliable narrator. The plot here is uncontrived, the resolution completely earned, and the style whole-grain simple until it blossoms into a final sentence of homonymic joy: "I stand up, then squint my eyes shut for (fore/four) a moment, remembering the night (knight) with Uncle Weldon when music soared (sword) through (threw) the air (heir), and the notes and the sky and our (hour) hearts were one (won)." sarah ellis (c) Copyright 2014. The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
A story about honorable living in the autistic-narrator genre that sets the bar high. Rose has a diagnosis of Asperger's, and her world of comforting homonyms, rules and prime numbers is repeatedly challenged by social interactions of which she has no innate understanding. Newbery Honor author Martin crafts a skillful tale that engages readers' sympathy for everyone portrayed in the story, even Rose's garage-mechanic, hard-drinking single father. He has given Rose a stray dog he found after an evening of drinking at the local bar, and Rose names her Rain. Through touching and funny scenes at schoolwhere Rose has an aide but is in a regular classroomand discomfiting scenes at home, readers come to understand how Rose's close relationship to Rain anchors her. But Rain goes missing during a storm, and when, with the help of her sympathetic uncle, Rose finds her dog weeks later, she is told that Rain was microchipped and actually belongs to someone else. Since following rules is vital to Rose, she must find Rain's original owners and give her dog back. Martin has penned a riveting, seamless narrative in which each word sings and each scene counts. There is no fluff here, just sophisticated, emotionally honest storytelling. (Fiction. 8-12) Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.