Review by Booklist Review
Elephant in the Dark is an amusing retelling of a poem by the thirteenth-century Persian poet Jalal al-Din Rumi. When a merchant returns to his village with a mysterious creature procured in India (an elephant), the villagers are impatient to see what it is. One by one, they creep into the dark barn and emerge declaring that they know exactly what it is based on contact with one part of the strange beast: a slithery nose, a tall sturdy leg, a floppy fan-like ear. Amid wildly differing guesses, the villagers argue over the animal's identity late into the night. Eventually, they learn the truth (which the reader knew all along), and it becomes clear that partial knowledge is a dangerous thing. Colorfully illustrated in the style of Persian miniatures, the book's depictions of the villagers approach caricature at times, as often occurs in Western renderings of Eastern cultures, and may merit classroom discussion. Pair with Ed Young's Seven Blind Mice (1992) for an alternate take on this folktale.--Chaudhri, Amina Copyright 2015 Booklist
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
Inspired by a Rumi poem based on the parable of "The Blind Men and the Elephant," Javaherbin offers a lively take on a classic story about the folly of a limited perspective. When a merchant named Ahmad brings a "mysterious creature" (an elephant) home and stores the animal in his barn, the villagers sneak in and attempt to identify it. One man, after touching the elephant's legs, declares that the animal is "round and tall, like a tree trunk!" Another, feeling its tail, reports that it is "skinny and hairy, like a paintbrush!" Taking cues from Persian miniatures, Yelchin creates a rowdy, bickering cast of villagers in turbans and vividly patterned garments, successfully playing up the story's comedic clashes. Ages 4-8. Author's agent: Abigail Samoun, Red Fox Literary. Illustrator's agent: Steven Malk, Writers House. (Aug.) © Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved.
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by School Library Journal Review
K-2-A merchant has brought a strange creature from India to a Persian village, and the locals are curious. The merchant puts off his neighbors because it is too dark in the barn and he wants to sleep. The villagers sneak in one at a time to figure out what is inside. Each one feels a different part of the animal, coming to a different conclusion about its identity. They are so busy squabbling among themselves that they miss seeing the elephant the next morning as the merchant leads it to the river. The villagers never see the wonder of the elephant because "they each knew only a small piece of the truth." This picture book is based on a poem by Rumi. Yelchin's illustrations are bright and colorful and filled with expressive faces. They take the story to an imaginative level. The story is told simply but with a meaningful impact. VERDICT Young readers and teachers who enjoy folktales with an entertaining moral will appreciate this story's message.-Kris Hickey, Columbus Metropolitan Library, OH © Copyright 2015. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Horn Book Review
Merchant Ahmad brings a mysterious creature to his village, all the way from India! While Ahmad sleeps, the curious villagers climb through a window in his barn and feel around in the dark, each touching just a part of the creature and leaping to conclusions about what it might be (a fan! a snake! a tree trunk!). The adult villagers begin to fight: Into the night no one listened, but everyone shouted and shoved. With a portraiture style drawn from Persian miniatures, Yelchin uses a variety of skin tones to portray the villagers, who wear brightly patterned and individually distinctive clothing. The story is much like Ed Youngs classic The Seven Blind Mice (rev. 3/92), but the emphasis here is on quarreling over small pieces of the truth rather than sharing knowledge to create a whole. The last (and wordless) spread, however, shows a group of childrenwith Ahmadgathered by the river the next day to watch the creature (an elephant) bathe. Yelchins gouache, acrylic, and ink paintings balance the repetitive patterns characteristic of the Persian style with lots of open space. Javaherbins authors note and additional appended information explain that she based her work on poet Rumis version of a story that goes back to the oral Buddhist tradition; the book should provide opportunities for rich discussions about perception and about advocating for what you believe to be true. susan dove lempke(c) Copyright 2015. The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
An Iranian-American author recasts an anecdote from the Persian poet Rumi, itself based on a far older tale about perceiving parts of a truth rather than its whole. Javaherbin adds characters and plot to the bare-bones original and reduces Rumi's lengthy mystical exegesis to a line. So curious are local villagers about the strange beast Ahmad the merchant has brought from India that they sneak into the dark barn where the creature is kept. Each returns with a different impression: one trips over the animal's nose and announces that it's like a snake, but it is more like a tree to one who feels its leg, and so on. Their squabble is so intense that they don't even notice when Ahmad arrives to lead the elephant out to the riverleaving each with "only a small piece of the truth." Yelchin outfits the villagers in curly-toed slippers and loose, brightly patterned caftans. He also puts a nifty spin on the story by leaving the adults to argue obliviously but surrounding the elephant at the wordless end with smiling, plainly clearer-eyed children. Though the language is bland, the wildly gesticulating figures in the illustrations add a theatrical element, and the episode makes its points in a forthright way. An excellent source note traces the familiar tale back to its earliest versions. Less stylish than Ed Young's classic Seven Blind Mice but a serviceable rendition nonetheless. (Picture book/folk tale. 6-8) Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
