Church of spies The Pope's secret war against Hitler

Steeped in primary sources and compulsively readable, this book should lead to a broad rethinking of Pius XII's action and inaction during the Nazi era. Also author of Wedge: The Secret War between the FBI and CIA (1994), Riebling (who has a background in political philosophy) depicts a Vatican deeply involved in covert political operations and willing to consider tyrannicide on the basis of Thomistic moral principles. Pius XII's direct role in three attempts to assassinate Hitler is one of Riebling's chief themes, though his central protagonist is Josef Müller--lawyer and leader of the Bavarian People's Party, hub of Catholic resistance to Hitler, during the Weimar Republic. Müller's contact with dissidents in the German military intelligence and his connections to such ostensibly disparate figures as Claus von Stauffenberg and Dietrich Bonhoeffer made him an indispensable link between Hitler's opponents in Germany and the Vatican. Riebling presents Pius XII's refusal to speak out forcefully against Nazism--a position that has been roundly condemned for more than half a century--as strategic rather than cowardly. Though never exonerating Pius for his few oblique statements about Nazi murderous anti-Jewish policy, Riebling portrays Pius as an implacable foe of Nazism and sheds light on the extent of Catholic resistance to an inhuman regime. Summing Up: Highly recommended. Upper-division undergraduates through faculty. --Steve Gowler, Berea College

Pius XII is sometimes referred to as "Hitler's Pope," and accused of worrying more about communism than the Holocaust. Riebling (Wedge: From Pearl Harbor to 9/11) asserts that instead of sitting passively while the Nazis ravaged Europe, Pius sponsored an intelligence network that sought for five years to assassinate Hitler. Rather than an organization in its own right, the Vatican spy network appears more like a loose association of the Pope's confidants who worked in conjunction with anti-Nazi groups that were comprised of religious figures and members of German military intelligence. The narrative's hero is Josef Muller, a German Catholic lawyer who served as a liaison between the Vatican and the German Resistance, and was one of the few conspirators to survive the war. VERDICT Clandestine organizations are hard to reconstruct and Riebling has mined an impressive array of archival sources to tell this fascinating story, although he tends to get bogged down in extraneous details. While Riebling tries to rehabilitate the Pope's reputation, he recognizes that the Pontiff's silence in the presence of genocide morally compromised him. Recommended for all libraries.-Frederic Krome, Univ. of -Cincinnati Clermont Coll. © Copyright 2015. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.

Riebling (Wedge: The Secret War Between the FBI and CIA, 1994), an expert on secret intelligence, compellingly explores the papacy's involvement in espionage during World War II. Pope Pius XII (1876-1958) was a political pope, and his was a pontificate of war. He valued science and technology and prefigured many leaders by installing an audio spying system in his library. The Holy See was actually hardwired by renowned Italian electrical engineer Guglielmo Marconi. In 1940, the Vatican proposed preventing future aggression with an Economic Union of Europe. The key component was Josef Mller, a Bavarian lawyer whose legal resistance to the Nazis led Heinrich Himmler, after first arresting him for treasonous conspiracy, to invite him to join the SS. Knowing Hitler's hatred for Catholics, and particularly Jesuits, Mller agreed to join the Vatican in facilitating connections between rebellious officers and England. He acted under orders from Adm. Wilhelm Canaris, chief of German military intelligence, as a double spy pretending to undermine the Vatican. Canaris was part of a wide conspiracy led by Gen. Ludwig Beck. Mller's travels between Germany and the Vatican included liaisons with the "Orders Committee" of Jesuits and Dominicans and made him one of the church's most valuable spies, even after his arrest. The pope claimed that Mller's exploits in smuggling, politics, and confounding the Nazis "worked wonders." This book has much to surprise, especially the many German officers, separately and together, involved in attempts on Hitler's life. There were many other "decent Germans" who hated Hitler, but they couldn't betray their "fatherland." Pius, vilified by critics who believed he ignored Germany's atrocities, comes off as a politically savvy man who realized his interference would precipitate Hitler's mortal overreaction against German Catholics. Not only a dramatic disclosure of the Vatican's covert actions, but also an absorbing, polished story for all readers of World War II history. Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.