Review by Booklist Review
Here is a cheerful, moving lesson on positive attitude and generosity. It stars Theodore, a lanky, mop-topped kindergartener who descends the stairs in his home one stormy school-day morning. Theodore finds a penny on one stair, with Abraham Lincoln, face up. Theodore pockets the lucky penny, and the day instantly improves. The sun comes out, the school bus is on time, and the bus driver announces that zoo penguins are going to visit the school. Readers follow Theodore through the school day, with all its lucky happenings. Theodore is chosen to show the day and date on the calendar; he gets called on to read his poem in class; he's the line leader coming in from recess. The illustrations, done in colored pencil, perfectly complement the original gloomy interior and the bright features of the school room and playground. In an unexpected twist, Theodore leaves his lucky penny under the bus driver's seat, knowing and showing that there is enough luck to share. Kadir Nelson's If You Plant A Seed (2015) would make a nice companion book.--Fletcher, Connie Copyright 2015 Booklist
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by School Library Journal Review
PreS-Gr 1-A gray day fills with sunshine after a young boy finds a lucky penny. When apple-cheeked Theodore sees the shiny face of Abraham Lincoln on the stairs, he can't believe his good luck. Tucking the penny into his pocket, he sets off for school with a new bounce in his step. Suddenly the clouds have rolled away, and the day is filled with a host of small joys: hitting the tetherball over and over without missing, being chosen as line leader, checking out a new book from the school library, and even answering a math problem correctly in class. Young audiences will easily relate to Theodore's happiness over these little victories, though the message that Theodore is essentially making his own luck, or rather finding it in the world around him, is subtle and may take some adult guidance to tease out of the narrative. Generous white space and Godbout's soft-edged colored pencil illustrations complement the gentle tone of Borden's text. For children new to school or those who struggle with anxiety, Theodore's lucky day may provide a quiet reminder of the good moments school has to offer. Other audiences may wish for something a little more out of the ordinary to happen. VERDICT A good option for one-on-one sharing, but overall, a supplemental purchase for libraries that simply can't meet the demand for back-to-school picture books.-Chelsea Couillard-Smith, Hennepin County Library, MN © Copyright 2015. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Horn Book Review
After he finds a penny, Theodore experiences a day full of good outcomes: the weather improves, he succeeds at tetherball, etc. Readers expecting a twist of fate won't find one, but they'll witness a rousing example of generosity: having realized his good fortune, Theodore leaves the penny behind for someone else. The cheery colored-pencil illustrations have an ultra-gauzy look. (c) Copyright 2016. The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
Theodore's gloomy morning improves when he finds a penny that brings him luck all day long. Or at least that's what he believes. It's hard to imagine anything bringing down Borden's mostly upbeat, positive protagonist. He compliments his mother, celebrates the sun, is happy to see his favorite bus driver, Slim, and believes his school's the best in the world. And things do go right for him: he's the calendar helper, has his poem read aloud, dominates at tetherball, and is the line leaderand that's just the morning. On the bus, after a chat with Slim about luck, Theodore secretly leaves the penny in a spot where Slim is sure to find it. "Theodore had found his own luck in a shiny pennyenough to give to a friendand enough for tomorrow, too." While kids may not be able to relate to the effervescent Theodore or ever imagine a day as good as his, those new to school may be comforted by the depicted routines of his day in kindergarten. Godbout's colored-pencil illustrations reflect the wide range of emotions children experience during the school day, and readers who look closely are sure to be rewarded by small, humorous details, though her rosy-cheeked and -nosed characters might take some getting used to. There's a little luck in each person's day; here's hoping young children's eyes are open to theirs. (Picture book. 4-7) Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
