Review by Booklist Review
*Starred Review* When travel writer, explorer, and diplomat, John Stephens read a 1836 antiquarian journal that mentioned the existence of monumental ruins in Central America, he decided that this would be his exciting next destination. Although he could write with engaging eloquence, he could not create the illustrations he knew the book-buying public would demand. Providentially, he met Frederick Catherwood, an Englishman who could, and who also was as passionate about exploration as Stephens. The partnership they formed shapes the lively narrative author Carlsen delivers about their ensuing expeditions to the region. The first, undertaken in 1839, entailed the panoply of perils (mountains, disease, hostile inhabitants) that exploration readers then and now expect, along with the added drama of a Guatemalan civil war. In addition to the discomforts endured by Stephens and Catherwood, Carlsen fully captures their awe before the ruins they described in word and image to such popular acclaim. Beyond their adventures, Carlsen credits the duo with an intellectual breakthrough about Mayan civilization: that it was an indigenous evolution, not derivative of another culture. Ably researching this pair and affectingly depicting their friendship, Carlsen makes an exemplary contribution to the lost-cities genre.--Taylor, Gilbert Copyright 2016 Booklist
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
Journalist Carlsen travels through Mexico, Guatemala, and Honduras, tracing the footsteps of Frederick Catherwood and John Lloyd Stephens, the amateur archaeologists whose 1839 expedition offered Euro-Americans their earliest awareness of Mayan civilization. At the time, the cultural and religious chauvinism of whites on both sides of the Atlantic encouraged the view that indigenous Americans had been nothing more than "primitive, inferior people." But Stephens and Catherwood's journey, as described through their pivotal writings, provided irrefutable evidence the Maya had created "one of the most sophisticated early civilizations on earth" and forced their readers to rethink basic assumptions about race, culture, and evolution. Carlsen depicts the two men's arduous expedition with verve and vigor, though some readers may find that the book's staccato narrative structure doesn't do the material justice. The book would also have been strengthened by at least a brief engagement with the longer history of European encounters with Central America; Hernán Cortés and his conquistadors had been dazzled by Aztec culture early in the 16th century, so at least some Europeans were aware that indigenous Central Americans were not savages. Nonetheless, Carlsen finely explicates the challenges of the Catherwood-Stephens expedition and the wonders they found. Agent: Geri Thoma, Writers House. (Apr.) © Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved.
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by Library Journal Review
Journalist Carlsen examines the adventurous lives of American diplomat, lawyer, and explorer John Lloyd Stephens (1805-52), and British artist and architect Frederick -Catherwood (1799-1854), whose many grueling archaeological expeditions through the dangerous jungles of Central America were among the first to document the majestic ruins of the Maya civilization. Stephens and Catherwood's investigation of then-unknown Mayan sites such as Copán and Palenque proved the existence of a highly sophisticated ancient indigenous civilization that challenged 19th-century views on Western cultural superiority. Combining Stephens's travel writing and -Catherwood's masterly illustrations, books such as -Incidents of Travel in Central America, Chiapas, and -Yucatan, as well as a later volume, became best sellers that introduced a mysterious, hidden world to an avid audience. VERDICT Carlsen's cogent and well-written dual biography successfully illuminates the fascinating tale of these intrepid pioneers of a lost civilization. For recreational readers or researchers interested in the rediscovery of Mayan culture, the history and archaeology of Central America, or archaeological adventure tales that make Indiana Jones seem tame. Readers may also enjoy the original works of Stephens and Catherwood. [See Prepub Alert, 8/31/15.]-Ingrid Levin, Salve Regina Univ. Lib., Newport, RI © Copyright 2016. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
Daring adventurers unearth a buried civilization. In his thrilling debut history, journalist and Pulitzer Prize finalist Carlsen traces the arduous journeys of lawyer John Lloyd Stephens and architect/artist Frederick Catherwood into the jungles of Central America. Both seasoned travelers to Rome, Greece, and throughout the Middle East, in 1839, when the two boarded a ship bound for the Gulf of Honduras, they had read only "vague reports of intricately sculpted stones" hinting at the existence of "a hidden unknown world." Those reports, and the intrepid voyages of naturalists such as Alexander von Humboldt, fueled their "hunger for adventure, the quest, the whiff of danger." Danger proved more than a whiff on 2,500 miles of life-threatening travelboth men contracted malaria and other tropical diseases, and civil wars ragedas they pursued their dream. In a battered Toyota, Carlsen followed their footsteps, and he evokes in palpable detail the tangled forests, punishing deserts, and cliffhanging mountain paths that they traversed. Stephens and Catherwood had no idea what to expect: common knowledge had it that Central America had been inhabited by primitive indigenous tribes. But they found shocking evidence of a sophisticated culture. "Architecture, sculpture, and painting, all the arts which embellish life, had flourished in this overgrown forest; orators, warriors, and statesmen, beauty, ambition, and glory had lived and passed away," Stephens wrote in a travel book, impressively illustrated by Catherwood, that became a bestseller. "It was a mystery," Carlsen writes, "of staggering implications." As the "acknowledged progenitor of American archaeology," Stephens could only guess at what he had found: he lacked the methodology and tools that would enable later archaeologists to date findings and flesh out Mayan history. A subsequent trip in 1841 yielded another volume, so eagerly anticipated that it was a bestseller even before "rapturous reviews" appeared. A captivating history of two men who dramatically changed their contemporaries' view of the past. Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
