Review by Booklist Review
Demi retells a Chinese folktale using artistic elements that reflect the story's culture. Her richly colored, delicate drawings are outlined with fine lines and emphasize patterns in nature and human action (notice the groupings of children). Cultural symbols, including colorful kites, foo dogs, yin-yang, animals of the zodiac, and traditional Chinese buildings, appear alongside children shown in classical clothing. All of the action occurs within large circles floating on a white background, lending a distinct once-upon-a-time feel while also reminding the reader of the value of sharing. Tan Tan, a spoiled rich boy, refuses to share his tree with Ping, a poor boy. But when he agrees to let Ping purchase just the tree's shade, Ping ends up with much more than either boy originally planned though eventually, he even shares his bounty with Tan Tan. Pair with The Little Tree That Would Not Share (2016), by Nicoletta Costa, for another way to be reminded of the virtues and joy of sharing.--Ching, Edie Copyright 2016 Booklist
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
Acclaimed for her elegantly illustrated picture-book biographies, Demi revisits another of her signature genres-Chinese folktales-in this graceful story of generosity trumping selfishness. Tan Tan, a "very rich boy" with exquisitely embroidered clothing and a chronic scowl, lives in an imposing house, playing by himself with his "very expensive toys" underneath a nearby tree. When he finds a "very poor boy" named Ping, previously seen in Demi's The Empty Pot (1990), enjoying the shade of the tree one day, an outraged Tan Tan insists that he owns the tree, but agrees to sell Ping its shade. Ping then follows the shade wherever it goes, including inside Tan Tan's home, inviting his human and animal friends indoors as well, and eventually forcing Tan Tan out of the house entirely. Demi replicates the simplicity and directness of her storytelling in lovely mixed-media pictures that feature miniature-scaled images, framed by unadorned circular borders, drawing clear contrasts between the boys' temperaments, and between the showy mansion and the simple pleasures offered by the tree. Ages 4-8. (Oct.) © Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved.
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by Horn Book Review
In this unsourced Chinese folktale (companion to The Empty Pot), rich, selfish Tan Tan sells poor Ping his tree's shade. But Ping follows the shade into Tan Tan's home and brings friends; enraged Tan Tan moves to "another house, where there...were no friends." When Tan Tan returns, Ping is compassionate. Demi's signature watercolor and mixed-media illustrations in neat circular frames complement the straightforward telling. (c) Copyright 2017. The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
A poor boy tricks a rich one into selling the shade of his tree.Demi returns with another Chinese-inspired tale rendered in her distinct, meticulous watercolors. Tan Tan is a rich boy who lives in a big house shaded by a large tree. One day he spots Ping, a poor boy, sitting under the trees branches and declares he owns all of the treeincluding its shade. Ping tricks greedy Tan Tan into selling him its shade. Much to Tan Tans dismay, Ping and his friends (both animal and human) sit in the trees shade wherever it lands: on Tan Tans bed and even at his birthday party. Frustrated, Tan Tan abandons his home to move into one with no tree, no shadeand no friends. Ping invites his friends to move into the empty house with him and soon accepts Tan Tans return with open arms. Like a folk tale, Demis story presents a bad-versus-good scenario with no gray in between. While Tan Tans selfishness is hardly admirable, trickster Ping cheerfully takes advantage of their agreement. When Tan Tans return is accepted without explanation or apology, readers cant tell whether this was Pings plan all along or whether he just had a sudden change of heart. Demis paintings are framed in large medallions on every page, her palette contrasting Tan Tans red-and-gold outfit to Pings simple white one. An oversimplified tale of greed and generosity. (Picture book. 3-6) Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
