Review by Booklist Review
Marquardt's latest is a gripping depiction of many of the issues facing Salvadorean refugees. Phoenix Flores Flores, 19, is a bright young man and former gang member determined to save his younger brother, Ari, from being forced into a gang. A traumatic journey through Mexico gets the brothers to Texas, where Ari, now mute, lives in a government-run shelter for refugees. Phoenix tries desperately to help from Florida, where he's been taken in by a kind lesbian couple. Meanwhile, 17-year-old Gretchen is struggling to recover from PTSD after a violent attack by a Latino gang member. Alternating first-person chapters from Phoenix and Gretchen describe their backstories and evolving situations as they meet and fall in love. But there's more to this intercultural romance: Marquardt's protagonists are complex and intriguing. Gretchen is both fiercely feminist and totally fearful after her attack; Phoenix is besotted and racked with guilt. Of special note is a terrific court transcript (with sketches by Ari) that effectively supplies missing puzzle pieces. Ari's sweetly satisfying epilogue provides a very happy ending.--Carton, Debbie Copyright 2016 Booklist
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by School Library Journal Review
Gr 9 Up-Seventeen-year-old Gretchen Asher's life has not been the same since she was mugged in a parking lot one night. The traumatic incident propelled her into a state of panic, and she is unable to go to school, socialize, or interact deeply with her boyfriend, Adam. Months later, while babysitting her niece and nephew in a neighborhood park, Gretchen spots a boy who looks nearly identical to her attacker. She is thrust back into the heart of fear, unaware that the boy, Phoenix, is in the midst of his own struggles. An 18-year-old immigrant from El Salvador, he has just spent four months escorting his brother to the United States to flee gang violence and is in danger of being deported. When circumstances cause Gretchen and Phoenix to continue meeting, they form an unexpected bond. While facing court trials, identity issues, and racial stereotyping, the teens bolster each other's courage. With the looming possibility of their permanent separation, the two must decide what is most important to them and what sacrifices are worth making. Tackling the issues of gang violence, immigration, mental health, and cultural bias, this is a compelling story that delivers profound messages through engaging, accessible prose. Both a page-turning romance and a comprehensive view of a young immigrant's experience, this novel is sure to encourage empathy and perspective among high school students. VERDICT A must-have for all YA collections.-Karin Greenberg, Queens College, NY © Copyright 2016. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Horn Book Review
Sometimes you dont realize you have PTSD until its triggered. That is more or less the case for Gretchen, after she sees a young man walking a dog and he reminds her of the trauma she suffered recently, when she was attacked and robbed. The boy in question, however, is not the robber. He is a teen with his own trauma to deal with: having been forced to join a gang back in El Salvador, Phoenix is now living in the United States with a pending hearing for asylum. (His younger brother, who also crossed into the U.S. illegally with Phoenix, is living in foster care far away from Phoenix.) Though screaming and running when you first meet someone, as Gretchen did, is not usually the best method of getting acquainted, the two find themselves brought together and helping each other heal from the betrayals and grief each has suffered. The story is told in alternating first-person chapters; Phoenixs story is especially compelling and unique, avoiding stereotypes about immigrants, poverty, or Latin Americans. The ending is a fairy tale, but the rest of the romance is happily not saccharine. Occasional drawings (ostensibly by Phoenixs brother) add texture and verisimilitude. sarah hannah gmez (c) Copyright 2017. The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
As in Dream Things True (2015), Marquardt explores the American dream, this time through the lenses of two traumatized teens. Gretchen, who's white, should be reveling in the moment as a high school senior. Instead, she's home-schooled since being robbed and assaulted in her Atlanta neighborhood has left her with debilitating panic attacks. In a nearby community, 18-year-old brown-skinned Phoenix, who escaped and rescued his younger brother, Ari, from gang violence in El Salvador, is staying with a compassionate lesbian couple while he awaits his day in court as an asylum seeker. Phoenix learned impeccable English from missionaries who established a bilingual school in his village, so he's able to communicate with Gretchen when they accidentally meet. Told in the teens' alternating voices, the enlightening story follows their growing relationship as they learn the traumatic experiences each has faced and help each other cope with them. The focus, however, is on Phoenix and Ari's grisly escape, witnessing acts that have left Ari mute in a juvenile detention facility, and their need to avoid returning to certain death in El Salvador. While the teens' relationship is tested when details from Phoenix's past coincide with Gretchen's case, a host of diverse characters lend a hand and offer varying perspectives. A rushed ending is only a small distraction in this otherwise eye-opening story. (Fiction. 14-18) Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
