Review by Booklist Review
Eighth-grader Gracie is certain that she likes A.J., but when she learns he likes her best friend, Sienna, she goes all out to help the two get together. She texts him on Sienna's phone for her as if she were Sienna, and she consults with Emmett, A.J.'s best friend and her neighbor. Emmett and Gracie have been best buds since they were little, and there's nothing they won't do for each other. But when Gracie turns 14, she's not certain if she can handle some of the shifts and changes that begin to take place. This modern, middle-school retelling of Cyrano de Bergerac is heartwarming, funny, and tender, offering a story of young love and loyalty, friendship and family. Characters are pitch-perfect for middle-school musings and milieu: a whirlwind of activity and emotional confusion that is the bane and fuel of any early teen's existence. Call it cute, call it clever Vail fluently captures the spirit of today's American middle-schoolers. See Kristina Springer's Cici Reno (2016) for another tween take on Cyrano.--Fredriksen, Jeanne Copyright 2017 Booklist
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
Before Gracie Grant was born, her older sister, Bret, was killed in an auto accident. As a result, Gracie's parents do everything in their power to make sure that Gracie, now 13, is never anything less than happy, a hard standard for Gracie to live up to. Whether at home or at school, Gracie insists that everything is fine, even when it isn't. Her social world gets complicated when she develops a crush on classmate AJ, who has a crush on Gracie's best friend Sienna. Gracie helps Sienna send AJ flirty text messages à la Cyrano de Bergerac, and the results create even more drama. Luckily Gracie has Emmett, her other best friend, but then things get complicated with him, too. Vail (Unfriended) skillfully details the politics of middle school, mean girls, first dates, and best friends in this sensitive and funny coming-of-age story. But it's the storyline revolving around Gracie's sister and her parents-and the resulting reflection on grief and the risks of loving another person-that leads to the story's most profound and memorable moments. Ages 11-up. Agent: Amy Berkower, Writers House. (Feb.) © Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved.
Review by School Library Journal Review
Gr 5-8-A modern, multicultural version of Cyrano de Bergerac. Gracie Grant, a tall eighth grader who has a prominent nose and hails from New York City, takes the lead as the Cyrano stand-in. Gracie's best friend, Sienna Reyes, needs help texting the boy who likes her, the handsome AJ Rojanasopondist. Unbeknownst to Gracie and Sienna, AJ gets help in responding to the texts from the witty but vertically challenged Emmett Barnaby. In addition, Gracie is coming to terms with the lifelong effects of losing a sibling. Bret, her sister, died in an accident before Gracie was born. Gracie's parents are understandably a bit overprotective, and she often wonders how her life would be different if Bret had lived. She is also facing the standard middle school angst: Is she pretty enough? Why isn't she as popular as other kids? Will a boy ever like her? The protagonist and her friends represent a variety of middle schoolers: a mean girl, a bullied kid, a sporty kid, a smart kid, the popular group, and outsiders. Yet Vail's portrayals prevent the characters from being mere stereotypes. Even Gracie's parents are fully formed, not the typically clueless adults who populate many books for kids. Readers will see themselves in Gracie and her friends, root for them, and likely figure out who is actually texting whom before the characters do, even if they haven't read the source material. VERDICT This tween romance proves that some stories stand the test of time, even with modernization.-Cindy Wall, Southington Library & Museum, CT © Copyright 2016. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Horn Book Review
Sometimes I get annoyed at Bret for being dead. Eighth grader Gracie never met her sister, who died three years before she was born. Gracie feels that she has to be a sunshine emoji to spare her overprotective parents more grief. Actually, she could really use the ear of an older sibling right now. Shes stuck in a Cyrano role, impersonating her best friend, Sienna, in texts to Siennas love interest, AJ Rojanasopondist--for whom Gracie has her own feelings. The text messages, a major element of the story, are handled as gracefully as possible in this medium: with a tinkly chime indicating the beginning of a text chain. Policano expertly interprets Gracies particularities (barbed wit, self-flagellation, an overanalytical streak) and she nails typical adolescent attributes when shes voicing Gracies peers: hair-trigger exasperation, brutal sarcasm, and sudden verbal paralysis. nell beram (c) Copyright 2017. The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
What if Cyrano were an eighth-grade girl in the 21st century?Gracie Grant has a crush on popular AJ Rojanasopondist, but AJ likes Gracie's best gal pal, Sienna Reyes. Gracie is a bit jealous upon hearing this news but soon decides sweet and adorable Sienna should be with AJ. The problem: Sienna is so unsure of what to text AJ, Gracie ends up doing it for her. As it turns out, text-AJ has a great sense of humor, one that is oddly absent in real life and is suspiciously like that of Gracie's best guy friend, Emmett Barnaby. Who is really on the other end of the texts? Gracie is fabulously sarcastic and a little neurotic, her first-person narrative thoughts pinging and ponging across the pages. Gracie's world is inhabited by a diverse group: Emmett is half-Filipino, half-Israeli; light-brown-skinned Latina Sienna speaks fluent Spanish; Gracie's classmates are "every combination of race and size," although Gracie herself is evidently white; and the school has a gender-neutral restroom. The sensitive subplot concerning Gracie's deceased older sister weaves in and out of the main plot, never overshadowing it but enhancing it with sincere emotion until the concluding chapters pull everything together. Hilarious and heartfelt. (Fiction. 12-15) Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.