Review by Choice Review
Service (fellow, Hoover Institution, Stanford), a prominent historian who has written the biographies Lenin (CH, Sep'01, 39-0484) and Stalin (CH, Nov'05, 43-1762), now tackles Nicholas II (1894-1917), last tsar of the Romanov dynasty, in the context of his participation in the Great War, his incarceration under the Provisional Government, and his termination under the Bolsheviks at Ekaterinburg in 1918. Despite White and Monarchist propaganda, books, and Bolshevik screeds, Nicholas II remains a controversial figure in Russian history. He was not prepared to rule when his father, Alexander III, died in 1894. He resisted any democratic tendencies in Russia, foolishly entered the Russo-Japanese War of 1904-5, and failed to understand the precursors of the Revolution of 1905. He fought the Duma and he fought his ministers. He insisted on "running" the army in WW I without military experience. Service makes clear that under no circumstances was it likely the royal family could have left Russia after the Bolshevik takeover and ensuing civil war, and that Lenin, Sverdlov, and Trotsky decided in 1918 not to put Nicholas II on trial in Moscow, but had him dispensed with by local Ural Bolsheviks. Service uses new evidence well, and it is clear why the Romanov dynasty came to a crushing end. Summing Up: Highly recommended. Graduate students/faculty. --Andrew Mark Mayer, College of Staten Island
Copyright American Library Association, used with permission.
Review by Booklist Review
Service is known for biographies of Lenin, Stalin, and Trotsky. Now, he documents the last months of Nicholas II, the tsar held accountable by the Bolsheviks for inflicting hardship on millions of Russians before the revolution. Service brings forensic detail to his account of the Romanov family's confinement and murder, mining newly available material that gives the story a you-are-there quality. It can be a tough read. Not only was Nicholas' family annihilated, other Romanovs all over Russia were brutally dispatched. One group of men and women was flung down a 60-foot mine shaft and left to die, a warmup for the Bolsheviks' consolidation of power by exterminating their enemies. Service weaves in threads of humanity: Nicholas, a disastrous ruler and anti-Semite, was a devoted father who made the captive hours pass by reading The Hound of the Baskervilles to his family. There are even heroes, such as lawyer Nikolai Sokolov, who smuggled proof of the murders to the West, ensuring that the world will never forget this horrifying piece of history.--Gwinn, Mary Ann Copyright 2017 Booklist
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Library Journal Review
Historian Service (emeritus, Russian history, Univ. of Oxford; The End of the Cold War) has written extensively about the history of modern Russia, and has authored biographies of Leon Trotsky and Vladimir Lenin. Here, he provides fresh -information about the events of 1917-18. While other historians have accurately written about the fate of the Romanovs, Service provides a thorough analysis of the reasons why the Romanovs were murdered, documenting the complicity of revolutionary Vladimir Lenin in this mission. The author shows the movements of the Red and the White Armies in the revolution that kept the Urals in a state of panic, and the White Army advancement on Yekaterinburg. The movement by the White Army provided the excuse and the impetus for murdering the whole Romanov family in the basement of the Ipatev house. Service documents the grisly details of the murder and the disposal of the bodies. Lastly, he delves into the politics and economics of the region during the Russian revolution, recounting the complete details of the last 17 months of the Romanovs. VERDICT Recommended for history buffs and serious Russian historians.-Harry Willems, Great Bend P.L., KS © Copyright 2017. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
A scholarly biography that goes beyond the gruesome depictions of the Romanovs' end to examine the more complicated nature of Nicholas II's character.Using primary sources and documentation unavailable to earlier scholars, British historian and Hoover Institution senior fellow Service (Russian History/Univ. of Oxford; Russia and Its Islamic World: From the Mongol Conquest to the Syrian Military Intervention, 2017, etc.) puts to rest any lingering doubts that the czar's entire family and retinue were summarily executed in the basement of the Ipatiev House in Ekaterinburg on July 17, 1918. The author provides persuasive evidence that Lenin and the leading Bolsheviks approved of the murders, even if there is no direct evidence of his ordering them. Service meticulously examines the Bolsheviks' dissembling after the fact; they were reluctant to admit to the entire family's massacre, rather than just Nicholas', because of the revulsion such an execution of innocents would inspire in Soviet citizens and the world. Nicholas, having ruled as czar for more than 20 years, was forced to abdicate on March 15, 1917, in favor of his brother, Mikhail, who refused the honor in turn. The family took refuge first at their retreat Tsarskoye Selo, outside of Petrograd, and then were moved to a Siberian exile for the next six months while there still was a Provisional Government. The transit to the Bolshevik bastion of Ekaterinburg in May 1918 was the last move. Service sifts through the record to give readers a sense of family life and routine during this fraught time, especially concerning whether Nicholas in any way altered his convictions in his own beliefs: "His actions were those of a ruler who always thought he was right." He continued to hold fast as "a nationalist extremist, a deluded nostalgist and a virulent anti-Semite." The author is particularly fascinated by Nicholas' choice of reading material, from which he learned to empathize with the lives of regular people perhaps for the first time. A compelling work; organized, concise, and chilling. Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
