Review by Booklist Review
McIntyre takes a good-natured jab at the invidious practice of prejudging strangers. Thrilled to hear that rats have moved into a first-floor apartment, five bunny sibs playing on the roof scamper downstairs to meet them. On the way, they gather the building's animal residents, from Vern (a sheep) and Walter and Matilda (pigs) to Granny Goat. By the time all get to the bottom, though, the grown-ups have decided that, since rats are known to be smelly, messy thieves likely to bury everyone in rat poop, the new arrivals have to go! In the cartoon illustrations, the downstairs trip escalates to a wild, uncontrolled tumble, dismal expectations expressed in larger and larger type. After all the buildup, said expectations fizzle after a bunny's timid knock brings Bertram and Natasha, a refined, dapper rat couple, to the door with a friendly invitation. Polite partings lead to a final wordless view of the rats' doormat, covered with small gifts. Even younger readers will understand how easily relations might have gotten off on the wrong paw.--John Peters Copyright 2019 Booklist
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by School Library Journal Review
PreS-Gr 2-When the bunnies of Pickle Lake apartments learn that rats have moved in downstairs, they set off on a rollicking trek down to greet them, gathering the rest of their animal neighbors along the way. McIntyre uses cumulative repetition and fun vocabulary to describe the movement of the animals as they hop and trot down the steps with increasing anxiety that rats are dirty and messy neighbors. The illustrations and arrangement of the text becomes increasingly crowded and chaotic, until reaching the unexpectedly tidy and welcoming apartment of the rats, Bertram and Natasha. The animals are depicted in vivid colors with expressive faces, and each character has a distinctive personality. The varied size and placement of text across the pages as well as the use of space and lines within the illustration serve to underpin the movement of the story. The cartoonish style uses saturated colors and contains humorous flourishes as the family of bunnies make mischief throughout the tale which culminates with an important lesson on making hasty generalizations about groups of people and animals. VERDICT The humor and fun vocabulary, as well as the engaging illustrations make this a storytime hit that may also be enjoyed independently.-Kelly Topita, Anne Arundel County Public Library, MD © Copyright 2019. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
When some mischievous (and none-too-neat) young bunnies and their older sister, Lettuce, hear the news that rats are moving into their apartment building, they are excited, but none of the other animal tenants share their joy.The othersa sheep, two pigs, polar bears, a couple of yaks, and Granny Goatvoice their objections to rats in terms most adult humans would use as well: "RATS! BIG, DIRTY, SMELLY, THIEVING, DANGEROUS RATS [who will] bury us alive in RAT POOP!" When the assembled tenants go to meet the titular "new neighbors" despite their escalating fears, the animals are very pleasantly surprised. Bertram and Natasha, each a "small, tidy, friendly-looking rat," invite them all in for "homemade cake." Bertram, the consummate host, manages to politely put his guests at ease by saying: "We know that rats aren't everyone's idea of the perfect neighbors!" The animals look properly abashed. This timely story about prejudice toward newcomers preceded by bad press is leavened by its comic, full-bleed, double-page illustrations that are full of action, speech balloons, and humorously dressed animals (yaks in bathrobes, Bertram in a natty bow tie and vest) as well as text that employs a cumulative effect as the animals join the parade downstairs. It is unfortunate that Bertram actually apologizes about moving in and that the two rats are so comically vanilla in their aspectsnone of the animal bigots must overcome their unreasonable fear of difference.This story about neighborliness and community will resonate, though it doesn't go as far as it needs to. (Picture book. 5-7) Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
