City of omens A search for the missing women of the borderlands

Dan Werb

Book - 2019

For decades, American hungers sustained Tijuana. In this scientific detective story, a public health expert reveals what happens when a border city's lifeline is brutally severed. Despite its reputation as a carnival of vice, Tijuana was, until recently, no more or less violent than neighboring San Diego, its sister city across the border wall. But then something changed. Over the past ten years, Mexico's third-largest city became one of the world's most dangerous. Tijuana's murder rate skyrocketed and produced a staggering number of female victims. Hundreds of women are now found dead in the city each year, or bound and mutilated along the highway that lines the Baja coast. When Dan Werb began to study these murders in ...2013, rather than viewing them in isolation, he discovered that they could only be understood as one symptom among many. Environmental toxins, drug overdoses, HIV transmission: all were killing women at overwhelming rates. As an epidemiologist, trained to track epidemics by mining data, Werb sensed the presence of a deeper contagion targeting Tijuana's women. Not a virus, but some awful wrong buried in the city's social order, cutting down its most vulnerable inhabitants from multiple directions. Werb's search for the ultimate causes of Tijuana's femicide casts new light on immigration, human trafficking, addiction, and the true cost of American empire-building. It leads Werb all the way from factory slums to drug dens to the corridors of police corruption, as he follows a thread that ultimately leads to a surprising turn back over the border, looking northward.

Saved in:

2nd Floor Show me where

614.4/Werb
1 / 1 copies available
Location Call Number   Status
2nd Floor 614.4/Werb Checked In
Subjects
Published
New York, NY : Bloomsbury Publishing 2019.
Language
English
Main Author
Dan Werb (author)
Physical Description
292 pages : illustrations, map ; 24 cm
Bibliography
Includes bibliographical references and index.
ISBN
9781635572995
  • Part I. The Host
  • 1. Welcome to El Bordo
  • 2. The Price of Something Purchased
  • 3. The Threshold
  • Part II. The Environment
  • 4. The Canyons and the Mesa
  • 5. The Beat
  • 6. Shore Leave
  • Part III. The Pathogen
  • 7. Mythmaking
  • 8. Modes of Control
  • 9. Causation
  • Part IV. Containment
  • 10. And Yet They Love Them
  • 11. The Bottom Line
  • 12. Endless Variation
  • Epilogue
  • Acknowledgments
  • Notes
  • Index
Review by Choice Review

In a narrative structured by the intersection of human trafficking, sex work, and drug abuse, Werb (UCSD) examines Tijuana's "micro-hyperepidemic" of HIV/AIDS, a hidden epidemic concentrated in people who inject drugs, sex workers, men who have sex with men, and transgender people. The book is organized into parts reminiscent of the epidemiologic triad (host, agent, environment) but with a twist. Though the four parts ("The Host," "The Environment," "The Pathogen," and "Containment") reference biological concepts, they depict the largely social dimensions of the situation. Werb first seeks to quantify the effects of Mexico's ley de narcomenudeo (drug trafficking law) on Tijuana's HIV population. His investigation of one epidemic uncovers another: embedded within Tijuana's HIV crisis is an epidemic of femicide. Weaving an intricate portrait of Tijuana's recent history, Werb follows a sequence of events leading from Tijuana's maquila slums to drug dens and then to the hallways of police brutality and corruption. In the end, this story leads its author back over the border to a critical viewpoint--looking north. Werb's investigation succeeds in reframing the discussion of many issues, including border policy, human trafficking, addiction, and the effects of US empire building. Summing Up: Recommended. General readers. Lower-division undergraduates through faculty and professionals. --Carlos A Hernandez, California State University, Northridge

Copyright American Library Association, used with permission.
Review by New York Times Review

DON'T LET ANYONE tell you that a preoccupation with reallife murders and murderers is morbid. Morbid is dashing off to Paris every other week to gape at the corpses on public display at the city morgue, which is what Charles Dickens and his friend Wilkie Collins did for fun. Morbid is expecting an entire nation to wear black because you are personally in deepest mourning, which is what Queen Victoria did when her beloved Prince Albert died. Morbid is collecting 19th-century deathbed portraits - although I doubt those half-dozen vintage photos on my desk constitute a "collection." Speaking of Queen Victoria, she was scandalized by the violent death of Lord William Russell, as recounted by Claire Harman in MURDER BY THE BOOK: The Crime That Shocked Dickens's London (Knopf, $26.95). "This IS really too horrid! " the young monarch reportedly wrote in her diary about the events of May 6,1840. "It is almost an unparalleled thing for a person of Ld William's rank, to be killed like that," she remarked, referring to the manner of his death. As Harman reports it: "His throat cut so deeply that the windpipe was sliced right through and the head almost severed." The Metropolitan Police soon arrested François Courvoisier, Lord William's new valet, who was rushed to trial and speedily hanged before a crowd of around 40,000. (A hard death, but not as cruel as the customary penalty of being drawn and quartered.) Harman, bless her, avoids the bogus stratagem of inventing dialogue for historical characters, relying instead on authentic literary sources like "Going to See a Man Hanged," William Makepeace Thackeray's first-person account of the hurly-burly of Courvoisier's public execution. "Many young dandies are there with mustaches and cigars," he dispassionately observes, along with "quiet fat family-parties, of simple honest tradesmen and their wives, as we fancy, who are looking on with the greatest imaginable calmness, and sipping their tea." Leaving those blasé spectators to sip their tea in the shadow of the gibbet, Harman turns an eye to those newly literate Londoners of humble origins who craved something exciting to read. Something like the so-called Newgate novels that romanticized bold crimes and celebrated the audacious criminals who committed them. For those thrill seekers there was "Jack Sheppard," a popular potboiler by William Harrison Ainsworth romanticizing a real-life 18th-century highwayman. This dashing rogue, like John Gay's Macheath revered as a folk hero, became a role model for young men eager to prove their manhood - or at least dream of it - through criminal derring-do. Although their heroes were celebrated in song and story, this fashionable "felon literature" was excoriated by literary critics for its "corrosive effect on readers' morals" and "pernicious influences" on youth. Sounds familiar. when did the midwest lose its wholesome reputation? In WHERE MONSTERS HIDE: Sex, Murder, and Madness in the Midwest (Kensington, paper, $15.95) M. William Phelps makes Iron River, Mich., sound like a cesspool of depravity and murder. Before the rot sets in, this small town seems "quiet. Secluded. Wide open. Generally flat. Friendly. Homey. And totally Midwestern." That notion evaporates once we meet Kelly Cochran, a player who collects men like toys and tosses them aside when they break. "It was a game to her," according to Phelps, who takes a more forgiving tone with the men (including Kelly's long-suffering husband) who put up with her shenanigans. So, Kelly is shameless - but is she a murderer? That's what Laura Frizzo, the "street-tough and strong-willed" police chief, intends to find out when one of Kelly's boytoys, clean-cut Chris Regan, goes missing. The case isn't all that complicated, but Phelps knows how to work it, mainly by fleshing out Kelly's character with prurient details about her sexual escapades and examples of her maddening game-playing. "A person does not forget where she dumped a dismembered human body," one fed-up detective grumbles. life is cheap in the Mexican border city that inspired Dan Werb to write CITY OF OMENS: A Search for the Missing Women of the Borderlands (Bloomsbury, $28). Hundreds of women die each year in the city of Tijuana and along the highway of the Baja coast, many of them from domestic violence, drug overdoses and H.I.V.-related diseases associated with the sex trade. Other bodies, often teenagers, turn up "bound and mutilated." Still others simply disappear. The author refers to all these deaths as "femicide - an epidemic of death visited upon the region's women solely because they are women." Werb attributes much of the region's social and economic ills to the collapse of Tijuana's thriving vice economy after 2009, when the city became off-limits to American sailors and Marines. No longer protected by the Yankees, working girls became fair game for predators along the border. "Their lack of income from a dwindling clientele pool forced them to choose johns who were sick or crazy, their potential for violence flaring like a beacon." An epidemiologist by profession, Werb often lapses into science-speak that bogs down the narrative. But he's a good interviewer and he respects the voices of his sources. One primary informant, a prostitute named Susi, speaks expressively about some of the friends she has lost: La Paniqueada, murdered in a hotel room by ajohn; Angie, hit by a car as she was running from the police; La Lobita, killed by her boyfriend; La Osa, who died of AIDS - and the friend she never speaks of: La Paloma, the Dove, one of the many women who were "levantarlo" (disappeared). These are only a few of the latest count (in 2013) of 1,200plus women who die under suspicious circumstances every year in the Mexican state of Baja California, but Werb says they represent "a microcosm of the population at risk of succumbing to the epidemic of femicide" and he's determined to give them back some humanity. HALLiE RUBENHOLD writes about another group of forgotten women in THE FIVE: The Untold Lives of the Women Killed by Jack the Ripper (Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, $27). The main fallacy Rubenhold wants to rectify is the accepted notion that Jack's victims were all prostitutes working in the alleys of Whitechapel. But from the position of their bodies alone, it seems obvious to the author that the victims were all homeless and sleeping rough, not trolling for customers. And while the sensationalist newspapers were quick to identify them as streetwalkers plying their "hideous trade," even the police weren't so sure about that, acknowledging "the difficulties in distinguishing a prostitute and her behavior from that of other poor, working-class women and their behavior." By going into their individual histories in great detail, Rubenhold makes a convincing case that, while each of the Ripper's victims might have been "a broken woman" or "a fallen woman," there's no evidence that they were doing business when they were killed. William Booth, founder of the Salvation Army, took a more charitable view of such street people. "To very many, even of those who live in London, it may be news that there are so many hundreds who sleep out of doors every night," he wrote in his study of poverty, "In Darkest England and the Way Out." "These homeless, hungry people are, however, there, but being broken-spirited folk for the most part they seldom make their voices audible." In giving these women their voices back, Rubenhold, a social historian, has produced a significant study of how poor and working-class women subsisted in an unforgiving age. Mainly, they got married, hopefully to someone who could hold down a job to support them and their large families. But they were hardly the slatterns history has made of them. Before falling on hard times, Elisabeth Stride once owned a coffeehouse. Kate Eddowes was quite musical; when her cousin was murdered, she composed a ballad in memoriam. Polly Nichols, a blacksmith's daughter who once worked as a maid, was schooled until the age of 15 and could surely read and write. Annie Chapman, the daughter of a valet, married a gentleman's coachman and lived with him and their children on his master's grand estate. Of all the Ripper's victims, she lived the most comfortable life before losing all those comforts when she became an alcoholic. Drink seems to have been the main reason Jack's victims slipped down the social ladder and wound up alone in the slums of Whitechapel. ("The female drunkard was considered an abomination," the author reminds us.) But the death of a husband, or a husband's loss of a job, could change any woman's fortunes overnight. Rubenhold doesn't transform these women into church ladies, but she's determined to save their sullied reputations. "The notion that the victims were 'only prostitutes,' perpetuates the belief that there are good women and bad women," she writes. "It suggests that there is an acceptable standard of female behavior, and those who deviate from it are fit to be punished." EVERYBODY LOVESA BAD GIRL - in Crime stories, if not in life. One person who meets that description is Florence Burns, the subject of Virginia A. McConnell's juicy biography, THE BELLE OF BEDFORD AVENUE: The Sensational Brooks-Burns Murder in Turn-of-theCentury New York (Kent State University, paper, $24.95). Coming of age at the turn of the 20 th century, the American-born sons and daughters of immigrants were not so keen on living by the austere moral codes their parents brought over from the home countries. There were so many amusing enticements in New York City: dance halls, gin mills and roadhouses for the adventures, the amusements at Coney Island for excitement, and fast cars with darkened back seats for sex. Florence Wallace Burns was one of those young rebels, her defiant behavior placing her at the extreme end of the spectrum. This wild child left school (under a cloud) after the eighth grade, got tossed out of the Sheepshead Bay Race Track for smoking, and hung out with the Bedford Gang, a group of bad boys. At one point, her exasperated father hired a private detective who found the poor man's errant daughter at a dancing pavilion in Coney Island. And on top of all that, she was boy-crazy. She started dating early and had a serious boyfriend by the time she was 16. Even at that young age there were signs that Florence was more than willful. When the boyfriend broke off that relationship, she hounded him so relentlessly that his parents had to send him away to prep school. Years later, when another boyfriend, Walter Brooks, rejected her, she shot him dead. She got away with it, too, because of what McConnell smartly calls "the Unwritten Law." By that reckoning, "once it was revealed that Walter Brooks had refused to marry her after supposedly taking her virginity and possibly getting her pregnant, the Unwritten Law was a subtext in the case." The thing is, that defense wasn't true. Florence hadn't been a virgin, she wasn't pregnant, and when Walter became involved with someone else, she made her intentions clear: "I will kill Walter unless he marries me," she told his own mother. Having done the deed, Florence was put on trial, but so thoroughly had she bewitched the jury, they acquitted her in less than an hour. "With such unanimity, it is not hard to imagine the jurors all taking out cigars or pipes or cigarettes to enjoy a smoke and give the illusion of an actual deliberation." McConnell's droll speculation offers a fair example of her extremely readable writing style, which is often sharp, but never nasty. She doesn't even make a big deal out of Florence's habit of carrying a gun in her muff - maybe not to the trial, but years later, she drew a piece from her muff and challenged the officer who was trying to arrest her: "One false move and there'll be one less cop." Spoken like a true lady. what would you do if you honestly believed that the world was on the verge of "a catastrophe of biblical proportions, one in which only the well armed and well prepared would survive"? Would robbing a bank seem like a smart move? That's what five California dudes do in norco '80: The True Story of the Most Spectacular Bank Robbery in American History (Counterpoint, $26), Peter Houlahan's alarming account of a bank heist that rocked the country in 1980 and reflected "the peculiar Zeitgeist of that decade" in all its cockeyed drama. George Smith's "evangelical zeal and deep belief in End Times theology" was the driving force behind the calamitous botched robbery on May 9,1980, of the Security Pacific Bank in Norco, Calif. A true believer in the coming apocalypse, George was desperate for money to build a secure bunker against the end of days. So he and his friend Chris Harven decided to recruit some guys they knew to rob a bank. As George later explained to an F.B.I. agent, he planned the entire robbery himself. "I told them. I cased the bank. I made the bombs. I did all that." Not his fault, really, but everything that could go wrong went wrong. Somebody forgot to lock the door, so bank customers kept coming inside. A helpful passing motorist stopped to put out the fire they had set as a distraction. Finally, through sheer incompetence, they find themselves with a hostage on their hands and no idea what to do with him. For a first-time writer, Houlahan sure knows how to dramatize a scene. His cinematic treatment of the robbery itself reads like wildfire, the fatal shootout with the police ends in colorful chaos, and the huge manhunt through San Bernardino National Forest conducted by "Hunt & Kill Teams" is a nail-biter. "Hundreds of heavily armed men were arriving with helicopters, dog teams, mounted search and rescue squads," along with the helicopter gunship and night vision goggles supplied by the military. But for my money, there's nothing quite as unnerving as the meticulously detailed descriptions of the militarygrade weaponry put into action throughout the story. Just for starters, there's a regulation .38 revolver, a modified-choke Wingmaster shotgun, a Colt "Shorty" AR-15, a Heckler .308 and, for some reason, a samurai sword. Gun control, anyone? MARILYN STASIO has covered crime fiction for the Book Review since 1988. Her column appears twice a month.

Copyright (c) The New York Times Company [June 2, 2019]
Review by Booklist Review

Epidemiologist and public-health expert Werb chronicles his search for the answer to the growing epidemic of deadly violence against women in Tijuana and how and why it widened as he discovered many other threats. He employs and explains at great length the data-mining strategies epidemiologists have used over the centuries to discover the root causes of epidemics such as anthrax and HIV, the study of which originally brought him south of the U.S. border. The pillars of epidemiology host, environment, and pathogen support the three main sections of the book, and a fourth discusses causation. Myth, science, the histories of sister cities Tijuana and San Diego, and fascinating conversations with sex workers, police, community organizers, and drug users figure in each section as Werb explores every hypothesis regarding women's deaths from HIV, drug overdoses, pollution, and other systemic forms of endangerment to its logical, if surprising conclusion. Werb's personal odyssey and unique approach offer valuable insights into the tragedy of femicide on the border, where communities on both sides are inescapably interdependent. A powerful addition to investigative coverage of the volatile borderland.--Sara Martinez Copyright 2019 Booklist

From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review

In this somewhat academic study, epidemiologist Werb investigates the massive rise in the murder rate for women in Tijuana beginning circa 2010, seeking the "pathogen" that could be causing it. Originally sent to Tijuana to study HIV, Werb quickly became aware that intravenous drug use and sex work were contributing to both the transmission of the virus and the increase in murders. He applied the precision-oriented tools of his trade to the nefarious practices of both the drug cartels and the Tijuana police. Werb learned that thousands of women migrate to the city each year seeking work at one of its many factories, then find themselves ensnared in the city's underworld; those who seek help from the police or a way out of heroin addiction through the methadone clinics often end up even more entangled. Werb's reportage is diligent; he speaks to sex workers, their customers, police officers, and fellow epidemiologists. Although his scientific language and deep dives into epidemiological practices make certain passages opaque, Werb shines a light on an outbreak of brutal crimes against Tijuana's most vulnerable population. This is a well-researched, pressing study relevant to a wide audience. Agent: Kirby Kim, Janklow and Nesbit Associates. (June) © Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved.


Review by Kirkus Book Review

An epidemiologist investigates the rash of female deaths in and around Tijuana.For the past decade, Tijuana has seen a drastic uptick in crime, most notably in the deaths and suspicious disappearances of women. After completing his doctorate in epidemiology and biostatistics in 2013, Werb traveled to the city to "dive into the purgatories Tijuana could produce," including the region's sex trade at Zona Norte and the arid, festering River Canal area. The author began his probing examination with a visit to a needle-exchange initiative. As a white Canadian, Werb stood out as he was escorted through the toxic cityscape to meet the indigent and drug-addicted people who call the storm drainage shafts and canal tunnels home. The author's steely focus and smooth, vivid prose make his encounters, which are often heartbreaking, come fully to life. He writes about how overdoses, murder, and rampant, untreated HIV have caused unprecedented deaths and disappearances in recent years, much akin to a surge that occurred in the late 1990s, when women vanished or were found dead by the roadsides. Illuminating the desperation of the area, Werb profiles a variety of residentse.g., an aged sex worker participating in drug-injection studies and an elderly "shooting gallery" gatekeeperand chronicles his collaborations with public health officials. The author also identifies known informational roadblocks, such as Tijuana's health care bureaucracy and police and amorphous Mexican cartel syndicates. Very little of Werb's spadework "tracking deaths backward in time" makes for easy reading, but his text shines a necessary light on Tijuana's epidemic of "femicide" and its unrivaled drug and poverty problems. While the statistics are increasingly staggering, the author, utilizing his epidemiological expertise, was able to uncover a "new syncretic agent of death" in the form of a lethal variety of street heroin.Werb cuts through the desolation to get at the truth of the region's vexing problem, but the solutions remain frustratingly elusive. Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.

Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.