Review by Booklist Review
In ancient Hawaiian culture, mhk are people who have both masculine and feminine characteristics they are in the middle. Based on a true story, Gale's picture book tells of a contemporary mhk child, Ho'onani. With the support of her teacher and parents, Ho'onani auditions for a role in a school performance of the hula chant a role traditionally reserved for males. Only her sister objects, planting a seed of doubt in Ho'onani's heart, but she continues on undeterred and tries out for the part, eventually proving herself strong and steady enough to be the group's leader. Ho'onani is simultaneously confident and nervous, but after some initial skepticism, the boys in her group embrace her as their leader. Bolstered by the support of her family, teacher, and friends, her performance is triumphant. Gale captures Ho'onani's feelings with clarity, and Song's crisp watercolor-and-charcoal illustrations are a lovely complement. A short documentary and curricular materials can be found at http://aplaceinthemiddle.org/.--Amina Chaudhri Copyright 2010 Booklist
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
Ho'onani, a Hawaiian schoolchild, identifies not as wahine (girl), or ka¯ne (boy), but just as herself (she uses she/her pronouns). Her parents are proud of her strength and independence: "She does what she wants!" her father says. But her sister Kana rolls her eyes when Ho'onani auditions for the traditional hula chant performance given by the high school ka¯ne, and says "How embarrassing!" when she's accepted. After working hard to internalize "the sway and song of story," Ho'onani is chosen as the group's chant leader: "When Ho'onani saw complete awe and true acceptance, she held her place. Strong,/ sure,/ and steady." Ho'onani confronts the possibility that the audience will resist a wahine leader, but in a triumphant conclusion, they acknowledge her gifts--and so does her sister. Boldly outlined watercolor and ink artwork by Song (A Friend for Henry) conveys visual information with strength that suggests Ho'onani's own. And Gale grounds the child's experience, based on a true story, in Hawaiian traditions, modeling showing "every person the same unconditional acceptance and respect." Ages 4--8. (Oct.)
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by School Library Journal Review
PreS-Gr 2--Readers are introduced to Hawaiian culture and nonbinary identities in this picture book based on the documentary A Place in the Middle. Though the author uses she/her pronouns throughout the book, Ho'onani doesn't think of herself as a girl or boy--she's just Ho'onani, and her refusal to conform frustrates her older sister Kana. When plans to perform a traditional hula chant are announced at Ho'onani's school, she decides to audition, even though historically only boys performed the chant. Not only is she selected to be a part of the chant, she's given the role of leader--with the support of the boys who will perform with her. Though Kana is initially unsupportive, her appearance at the final performance wraps things up with a happy ending. Song's illustrations are boldly drawn, with thick lines and angular features. VERDICT An affirming story of a gender identity little represented in children's literature. This book is an excellent purchase for libraries looking to expand their LGBTQ+ offerings.--Katherine Barr, Cameron Village Regional Library, Raleigh, NC
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Horn Book Review
When Ho'onani, who doesn't "see herself as a wahine, 'girl'...or kāne, 'boy,'" auditions to participate in the traditionally all-male hula chant, she not only wins a spot--she's named the group's leader. This story is inspired by a documentary about the ancient Hawaiian concept of a third gender "embracing both feminine and masculine traits." The illustrations' sun-bleached colors and minimal backgrounds focus on Ho'onani's self-assured presence and on the powerful chant's performance. (c) Copyright 2021. The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
In this picture book based on a true story, a nonbinary youth finds her place as a hula warrior. Hoonani Kamai doesn't identify with either wahine (girl) or kne (boy); "she prefer[s] just Hoonani." (Feminine pronouns refer to Hoonani throughout.) One day, her teacher Kumu Hina announces auditions for a traditional hula chant the high school kne will perform. With Kumu Hina's encouragement, Hoonani auditions despite the shock of the kne. After passing the test, she practices "until Hawaii's history [becomes] a part of her." Practice pays off, as her chant's strength and power gain her true acceptance as their leader. Kumu Hina warns that people may get upset that a wahine is leading, but Hoonani faces the performance with courage. Through every challenge and doubt, Hoonani "[holds] her place. Strong, sure, and steady." Her strength and bravery lead her to find her place as a hula warrior. Based on the documentary A Place in the Middle, this story brings to light the Hawaiian tradition of valuing those who are mh, or nonbinary. Teacher and activist Kumu Hina creates a place of safety and acceptance, encouraging her students to treat others with respect. Hoonani's courage to be true to herself and her place in the middle is empowering. Hawaiian words are intermixed, and Song's illustrations are full of emotion and determination.Hoonani deserves a place on any shelf. (author's note) (Picture book. 4-9) Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
