Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
Early in Clare's chilling sequel to 2019's The Woman Who Spoke to Spirits, Georgiana Long, a teacher at Shardlowes, a girls' boarding school in the English fens, arrives one winter day in 1881 at the London office of Lily Raynor, the proprietor of World's End Bureau, a private enquiry agency. Three students have run away on separate occasions in recent months, and Georgiana, who doesn't trust the police, wants Lily to investigate. Intrigued, Lily agrees to fill a temporarily vacant staff position at Shardlowes in order to do so. Lily has her lone employee, Felix Wilbraham, look into the school's secretive benefactors, the Band of Angels, and he pursues a trail that leads to Scotland. Shifts between Lily's inquiries and Felix's help jack up the suspense. The two capable and self-assured leads stand in contrast to such stock secondary characters as the ambitious headmistress and the caretaker too fond of his whiskey. Descriptions of the bleak winter landscape of the fens ("the naked trees like skeletal limbs clawing up at the grey sky") lend atmosphere. Anne Perry fans will want to check this out. Agent: Sophie Gorell Barnes, MBA Literary (U.K.). (Dec.)
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by Library Journal Review
In this next mystery in the 1880s London-set series starring private investigators Lily Raynor and Felix Wilbraham (after The Woman Who Spoke to Spirits), Lily is called on to impersonate an assistant matron at the Shardlowes School. Her aim: to discover what happened to several vanished pupils.
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
Clare's second foray into the Victorian past discloses new information about her unusual heroine. Private investigator Lily Raynor, who solved a complicated mystery in The Woman Who Spoke To Spirits (2019), is barely eking out a living for herself and her employee, Felix Wilbraham, when she's offered a job by Georgiana Long, a teacher at Shardlowes, a school for women in the Fens. The school is supported by the Band of Angels, a shadowy philanthropic organization founded by the MacKillivers, a pair of Scottish twins, one of whom has a mental illness. Several of the Shardlowes girls, many of them mentally or physically challenged, have gone missing from the school. Eager to avoid a scandal, Miss Long asks Lily to pose as a nurse at the school. Lily trained as a nurse, a profession she loved yet left after a mysterious incident in India. She goes to Shardlowes feeling a good deal of trepidation, but she fits in easily and soon begins to uncover disquieting facts about the missing pupils while Felix, with the help of his journalist housemate, tracks down the first girl to go missing, Esme Sullivan, whose body turns up in the water in Portsmouth. Traveling to Scotland, Felix discovers things that make him fearful for Lily, who's uncovered information that puts her in grave danger when another child is stolen. The experience that formed her in India makes her determined to reveal the truth. Mystery and social commentary combine in a heartbreaking and sadly relevant tale. Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.