Review by Booklist Review
In this rather gloomy treatise on the state of global affairs, Ryan (Sex at Dawn, 2010) muses about civilized societies and how we're all basically doomed. Instead of hoping for salvation from some time-traveler from the future, he suggests we look to the past, specifically back to prehistoric hunter-gatherers. He considers various negative aspects of modern life ranging from food, dental health, and childbirth to teenage sex, communicable diseases, work environments, love, war, violence, and organized religion, and compares these current sorry states of affairs to similar, presumably preferable life events experienced by early humans or found in isolated societies. But it's not all gloom and doom. There are occasional wry observations and several humorous quotes from Mark Twain sprinkled throughout the brief chapters. His conclusion? We should return to our origins, stop obsessing over quantity more more more! and refocus instead on quality of life, for everyone. Whether or not readers agree with his pessimistic outlook or chafe against his fatalistic assertions, his writing is engaging, extensively documented, well-organized, and thought provoking.--Kathleen McBroom Copyright 2010 Booklist
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
Modernity is toxic, brutal, and insane compared to the blithe existence of ancient and contemporary hunter-gatherers, according to this fervent jeremiad. Ryan (Sex at Dawn) paints a rose-tinted portrait of nomadic "foragers" who lead healthy, happy, peaceful lives in "an egalitarian world of shared plenitude"; value "generosity, honesty and mutual respect"; work just 20 hours a week; enjoy sex with multiple partners; and respect women and LGBTQ people. Unfortunately, with the arrival of agriculture and fixed abodes, the foragers' "gods of ease and play, pleasure and laughter" succumb to civilization's "god of toil, sacrifice, scarcity and submission." The results are disastrous: patriarchy, war, high-carb diets, cancer, sexual repression, environmental destruction, tooth decay, "rich asshole syndrome," overprotective parenting, and toilets that thwart humans' natural squatting posture. Ryan updates the centuries-old theme of mankind's "fall from grace" with a one-sided selection of anthropological and psychological studies, while jousting with pro-civilization ideologues such as Steven Pinker. He notes the high rates of childhood mortality among hunter-gatherers, and concedes that prehistoric foragers developed agriculture to keep from starving, but reckons death "a relatively minor event" when capping a gloriously uncivilized life. Ryan's anti-progress polemic is entertaining and provocative, but not very convincing. (Oct.)
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by Kirkus Book Review
Hunter-gatherers were happier, wiser, and healthier than we are.Journalist Ryan (co-author: Sex at Dawn: The Prehistoric Origins of Modern Sexuality, 2010), host of the podcast Tangentially Speaking, is convinced that the idea of progress is insidious propaganda propelling the world to economic, ecological, and political collapse. "Every day," he asserts, in one of his many broad generalizations, "more people conclude that the approach to life promoted by the central myths of civilization are generating loneliness, confusion, anxiety, and despair for many of us." Most people, he claims, are unhappy, working in jobs they hate, eating food that has been leached of nutrition, living in overcrowded cities where they are cut off from nature and from one another, and suffering from diseases that "are by-products of civilization itself"not only scourges such as tuberculosis, cholera, smallpox, and influenza, but also tooth decay, constipation, hemorrhoids, depression, gout, "coronary heart disease, obesity, hypertension, type 2 diabetes, many types of cancer, autoimmune disease, and osteoporosis." To counter what the author sees as the mistaken Narrative of "Perpetual Progress," he recommends looking closely at how our distant ancestors lived. Drawing on a diverse mix of academic and popular science, Ryan concludes that all hunter-gatherers lived "in strikingly similar ways." They were "fiercely egalitarian," had free mobility to "easily walk away from uncomfortable situations," and saw themselves "as the fortunate recipients of a generous environment and benevolent spirit world." They happily shared property, had access to all they needed, did not discriminate on the basis of gender, and eased their way to death by imbibing psychedelics. Their downfall came from farming. Once they adopted agriculture, their social structure changed, becoming hierarchical, competitive, and overpopulated. "Measures of health, longevity, security, and leisure all declined for almost everyone," writes the author, including the elites. Ryan's solution to the chaos of contemporary life is simple and simplistic: to bring "hunter-gatherer thinking into our modern lives" by forming "horizontally organized collectives," using "nonpolluting locally generated energy," and offering "a global guaranteed basic income that incentivizes not having children."A nostalgic portrayal of the prehistoric world with little relevance for our current era. Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
