Review by Booklist Review
In 1998, Surya Bonaly stunned the figure-skating world with the move that would become her signature, a backflip landed on one skate. This inspiring picture-book biography charts Bonaly's path through competitive skating, highlighting her power, talent, and unbreakable spirit, even when judges penalized her for not conforming to their ideas of what skating (and skaters) should look like. "The judges didn't want a / Black figure skater, skating the way she wanted." This statement is paired with an illustration of Bonaly staring defiantly forward, her bold eyeshadow sparkling, while identical white skaters pose crowned behind her. Williams does an excellent job capturing Bonaly's dynamic, athletic skating style and eye-catching costumes, pulling together visual montages of the French skater's performances and fondness for jumps. Readers will feel for Bonaly as Olympic gold slips through her fingers when she achieves yet another second-place finish, and they'll cheer when she lands her backflip--though the text's poetic phrasing may confuse readers into thinking she took gold with this victorious performance, which she did not. Extra facts about this groundbreaking athlete conclude.
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by School Library Journal Review
K-Gr 3--This illustrated biography of French figure skater Surya Bonaly is told in poems ("Her Dawn," "Her Dream," "Her Rise," etc.), with artwork as vibrant and glittery as an Olympic routine. Bonaly, who is Black, was adopted and renamed by white parents at 18 months. She showed early talent as a figure skater and worked hard to become the French champion and European champion. However, at the highest levels, it seemed, "The judges didn't want a/ Black figure skater,/ skating the way she wanted./ And, maybe,/ they didn't want a/ Black figure skater/ at all." Refusing to accept second place, Bonaly learned to skate how the judges wanted, but ended her Olympic career by landing a defiant backflip on one skate, a move that has not been attempted before or since. Perhaps due to the poetic nature of the text, some details are unclear, although back matter includes more, along with photographs. Williams's painterly digital art infuses the dynamism of live figure skating into the spreads; she shows Bonaly in a variety of athletic poses, including her trademark backflip, and wearing different costumes, hairstyles, and makeup. Certain active words in the text are accentuated for their meaning and contribute to the sense of movement the illustrations create. VERDICT A tad uneven, but with standout illustrations; a good choice for libraries where books about groundbreaking athletes such as Raven Wilkinson (Leda Shubert's Trailblazer) and Misty Copeland (her own Firebird) are popular.--Jenny Arch
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
