The seat of the scornful

The British Library Crime Classics reprints one of Carr's few novels not to include one of his signature locked rooms or impossible murders, first published in the U.S. in 1942 as Death Turns the Tables. Aglow at her marriage proposal from nightclub partner Anthony Morell, Constance Ireton has finally screwed up the courage to introduce Morell to her father, dour Justice Horace Ireton, leaving the two men alone to get acquainted. Predictably taking against the suitor who has a shady past and who he thinks can't hold a candle to barrister Frederick Barlow, a friend of Connie's from childhood, the judge asks how much he'll need to pay Morell to send him packing. They agree on a sum and arrange to meet at Ireton's home the following evening to hand off the cash. When a plea for help to the telephone exchange brings the police, they find Morell shot dead with a most surprising item in his pocket and the judge nearby. The case against Ireton is so strong that his old acquaintance Dr. Gideon Fell, who just happens to be on hand, announces that the question Inspector Graham must answer is not "Whodunit" but "Did he, or didn't he?" As Martin Edwards observes in his introduction, Carr is less interested here in presenting an impossible scenario than in plumbing the moral question of whether murder is ever justified. Despite the absence of any locked rooms, the clueing is as intricate as ever; if fans find fault, it'll more likely be with the piling of incident on unrelated incident in the story's second half and the outsized role improbable coincidences play in the mystery's solution. Second-best Carr is still a potent brew. Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.