Review by Booklist Review
When Remy Wadia returns to Bombay from his home in Ohio to adopt a baby and visit his mother, he learns that the baby's birth mother, Monaz, is rethinking her plan to give up her child for adoption, and discovers that his own mother, Shirin, has been hospitalized for pneumonia. These quick plot turns highlight life's unpredictability, a theme that runs through the book. As Remy learns harsh truths about his parents' choices and comes to understand how they determined the course of his life, he also gets an opportunity to define the man he wants to be. Remy's fractured relationship with his ailing mother provides a strong story arc, and his complicated love for his birth city makes for a meditative study of Bombay in its many moods. The story of the Wadia family is a sensitive exploration of love in its different forms--romantic, maternal, filial, platonic--and forgiveness. Umrigar's fluid prose and well-wrought characters capture the milieu of the Parsi community past and present. Paired with the emotionally demanding story line, this is a compelling read.
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
Umrigar (Honor) returns with another rich and emotionally gripping story about familial love and the destructive power of secrets. Remy Wadia has returned from the U.S. to his hometown of Bombay for the first time since his father's death three years earlier. Having arrived to adopt a baby from a pregnant teenager, Remy is shocked to learn that the mother-to-be is having second thoughts about giving up the child. Making matters worse, his elderly mother's health has suddenly declined. Remy, who has a turbulent relationship with her, is guilt-ridden for having left India to settle with his American wife in Ohio. Umrigar deftly explores the complexity of caring for an aging parent as Remy stretches himself thin trying to nurse his mother back to health. Meanwhile, he's preoccupied by grief over his beloved father. After his mother begins to recover and comes back home from the hospital, Remy tries to forgive her for verbally abusing him as a child, until one morning when a photograph falls out of his mother's prayer book, leading to a series of revelations about Remy's parents that change his perceptions of both of them. The story of family secrets takes on emotional resonance as Remy contends with his own anxieties about becoming a parent. Umrigar continues to impress. Agent: Gail Hochman, Brandt & Hochman Literary Agents. (Sept.)
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by Kirkus Book Review
An Indian man living in Ohio returns to Bombay for the first time since his beloved father's death. After struggling with infertility, Remy Wadia and his wife, Kathy, have a stroke of luck: a relative of one of Remy's closest friends from childhood is pregnant and wants to give the baby up for adoption. Remy arrives in India to meet the young woman only to find she wants to keep her baby. That's not the only disappointment waiting for him. His mother, with whom he has a thorny relationship, is in the hospital fighting for her life. These events rock Remy to his core, sending him into a tailspin of grief, bewilderment, nostalgia, displacement, and guilt. At risk of losing his mother, Remy discovers a family secret that upends everything he thought he knew about her and his father, transforming the notion of the man he thought he was and wants to be. Being both at home--meaning Bombay, the city where he was born and raised--and away from home--meaning Columbus, the smaller city where he's made a life for himself as an adult--is challenging, but it offers him the opportunity to unpack the revelations from the past as well as think about what he wants for his future. Umrigar knows how to tell a story. A former journalist and the author of nine previous novels, she creates interesting characters and complex relationships, builds thematic tension and narrative suspense, and delivers emotionally resonant moments at just the right pace. The book isn't perfect. The dialogue often feels pedantic, as do some of Remy's internal soliloquies about the differences and parallels between the U.S. and India. But these shortcomings are a small price to pay for an otherwise rich, heartfelt novel. This is a touching story about what it really means to grow up and into an authentic life. Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
