Review by Booklist Review
The authors of the Adventures Guild series unearth something frightful in their new middle-grade series. Known as one of America's most haunted cities, the seaside town of New Rotterdam is no stranger to unexplained disappearances. Protagonist Emrys Houtman has recently moved to the area, and he counts himself lucky to find camaraderie with Hazel and her curt friend Serena, apartment neighbors who share his passion for horror. Emrys and Hazel bond over "The Doomsday Archives" page of the New Rotterdam Wiki Project, where they log all unnatural events occurring in town. When the kids inspect unusual activity in their upstairs complex, they discover a talking, anthropodermic book that transports them into another realm of supernatural relics. They are given the chance to join the Order of the Azure Eye and prevent disappearances involving an ominous, blood-red hourglass. Only time will tell if this trio possesses the confidence and strength to stop these disturbances before others disappear. Clark and Eliopulos expertly build heart-pounding suspense by intercutting the story's action with illustrations and wiki entries on past supernatural occurrences, formatted to resemble Wikipedia pages. The book champions accept each others' quirks and weirdness, which will resonate with anyone who's struggled to fit in. A superb choice for fans of Jonathan Stroud's Lockwood & Co. series, Tom Booth's Eerie-on-Sea books, and creepypastas.
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
A terrifying local legend tests the mettle of a resolute trio of sixth graders in the first installment of this grisly horror series by Loran Clark (The Lock-Eater) and Eliopulos (the Minecraft Stonesword Saga). Emrys is excited to move to New Rotterdam despite the town's gloomy atmosphere; after all, it's a "hot spot for urban legends," and the home of his best friend Hazel, a fellow creepypasta fanatic and cataloger of New Rotterdam lore on the town's active wiki. Though he feels like a third wheel around Hazel's childhood friend and cryptid skeptic Serena, Emrys champions teamwork when a power outage prompts the middle schoolers to investigate a shadowy neighbor's ruined apartment, from which they're hurled into another dimension embroiled in a conflict between two opposing magical organizations. Guided by a deadpan talking spell book, the friends confront a demonic hourglass named The Wandering Hour that spells gruesome doom for anyone who gazes upon it. This dark plot-driven adventure, sprinkled with insightful New Rotterdam wiki entries, winking humor, and heaps of horror sensibilities, is unsettlingly creepy. Emrys and Hazel are white, and Serena is Black. Final art not seen by PW. Ages 8--12. Agent: (for Loran Clark) Ammi-Joan Paquette, Erin Murphy Literary; (for Eliopulos) Josh Adams, Adams Literary. (Jan.)
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by School Library Journal Review
Gr 3--7--The coauthors of "The Adventures Guild" trilogy have written a fantastical horror set in New Rotterdam, a small seaside town teeming with urban legends and mysterious disappearances. Eighth grader Brian Skupp encounters an hourglasslike object on his school bench. As he's studying it, he notices everyone is frozen in time. Keys don't fall. People don't move. The only person who seems to see him is a moving ghostlike woman with fangs. The ominous phrase, "He was never heard from again" segues into one (of many to come) wiki articles about mysterious happenings in the area. The book starts again with three present-day friends, Emrys, Hazel, and Serena, and their story of how they found the Doomsday Archives. The hourglass makes a comeback, as do a variety of life-threatening monsters who like to swallow things, and weird occurrences, such as the Midtown Mummy, an ember bishop, and a wandering hour. This would be a good read-aloud for a middle school class for the month of October, especially if paired with their town's local urban myths. VERDICT A story about kids helping keep their town and neighbors safe will speak to those who love to sink themselves into a different realm and play armchair detective/hero, this is a great choice for middle grade shelves.--Tanya Boudreau
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
Three kids gain access to magic in a fight against their town's evil underbelly. New Rotterdam has so many strange occurrences that it has its own wiki to keep track of them. Emrys is new to town and delighted to live in one of America's Most Haunted Cities. He resides in the same apartment building as Hazel, his old camp friend, who shares his interest in all things spooky, and Hazel's friend Serena, who does not. All three, however, are equally fascinated with their reclusive penthouse neighbor, Mr. Van Stavern. One night, they find his apartment trashed and him trapped within the pages of a grimoire. Mr. Van Stavern inducts the trio into the Order of the Azure Eye--a group dedicated to protecting occult relics--and gives them access to the Blue Reliquary, a magical space holding those items. And just in time, because people are disappearing in New Rotterdam, and Emrys, Hazel, and Serena are the only ones who can stop the evil forces at work. The wiki framing is clever, providing readers with background information and mirroring how many tweens would begin their own research. Legitimately scary scenes resolve quickly, with resolutions driven by the kids' strengths and actions. A big reveal at the end promises exciting developments in future installments. Emrys and Hazel are white; Serena, who has dads who are Black and Dominican, is Black. An engaging start to a promising new series. (Horror. 8-12) Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
