Review by Horn Book Review
This visually and metaphorically resonant picture book follows a child living through a day when they are not "sunshine yellow" or "balloon bright." Instead, they describe themself as "gray today. I just am. I am gray. Gray is when I don't feel like me." Dockrill uses simple and evocative metaphors to reflect a feeling to which many young readers and listeners (and probably many older ones, too) can relate, and to demonstrate the bleakness of dour thoughts. A sympathetic caretaker provides gentle reassurance that the colors inside a person don't go away, even on gray days, and their love for the protagonist won't go away either. Child's distinct mixed-media illustrations, with engagingly varied compositions, shift between grayscale and sunny hues to create a contrast that embodies the sense of being "gray like the storm in the clouds" in a colorful world. The text lets readers and listeners accept feelings of darkness, and reminds them, "It's OK to feel gray." The art manages to convey both the protagonist's emotions and the wonders that can be present on an average gloomy day. Altogether a welcome reminder that even on the grayest days, hugs (and support from others) can help, and color can return. Allison PriceJuly/August 2024 p.97 (c) Copyright The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
Color words signal emotions. Children understand that colors often suggest feelings: The brighter the hues, the happier the sentiments. As this book opens, a kid looks out forlornly and announces, "Today, I am gray." The illustrations confirm it, as do the child's explanations: "I don't feel sunshine yellow or orange balloon bright or treetop green." Not even "night sky black." Everyone's had days when they feel like "the scribble on a page," "the storm in the clouds," "the puddle in the road," "the tea when it's gone cold." The protagonist says that it's OK to feel gray, as if all the colors have gone; you don't have to be bright every day. The good news is…storm clouds that bring rain also bring splashy puddles and the sun. And while you may feel gray like the sidewalk, later you can scribble on it…using whatever colors you choose! Better yet is a loving parent telling you, "All of these colors are your feelings…and each one of them is still inside you." The best news is a parent saying "I love you however you are feeling…and my love won't change, even when you're gray." Kids will warm to this sweet, understated U.K. import and feel heartened by the caregiver's comforting reassurances. Youngsters should feel their own moods, notoriously mercurial in childhood, validated. The mixed-media illustrations are appealingly childlike--and, unsurprisingly--colorful. Parent and child have lightly tanned skin. This wise charmer will help brighten readers' feelings. (Picture book. 4-7) Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.