Review by School Library Journal Review
Gr 4--6--In this sequel to the Book of Stolen Dreams, Farr sends readers on another fantastical journey through Krasnia and the Hinterland that lies beyond. Dark-haired, brown-eyed Rachel Klein has recently defeated the dictator Charles Malstain, but something is wrong. The boundaries between this world and the one beyond have become porous. As Keeper of the Blood-Red Key, Rachel must find a way to set things to right and, in the process, rescue an innocent nine-year-old girl--Elsa Spiegel--from a fate worse than death. In this book, Farr adeptly builds out the world of Krasnia. He repurposes Greek mythology to give us the Hinterland, a place filled with winged ferrymen, corrupt paper-pushers, and the residents of Liars' Lair, Burglars' Burrows, and Tyrants' Tower. The author keeps tension high by placing a strict time limit on Rachel's quest. He also adds levity by assigning each of the children in the Hinterland an animal companion to follow them on their journey. VERDICT An engaging, fast-paced book well suited for fans who enjoy fantasies similar to Philip Pullman's "His Dark Materials."--Talea Anderson
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
This sequel to The Book of Stolen Dreams (2023) again pits siblings Rachel and Robert Klein against the forces of evil. Twelve-year-old Rachel and her older brother have become national heroes after saving their country of Krasnia from malevolent dictator Charles Malstain, whom they've permanently (or so they believe) sent to the Hinterland, the world where the dead go. Alas, getting rid of one evil person doesn't solve everything, and greedy nobles Horace and Mary Trueblood are determined to use the Hinterland to cheat death and live forever--at the expense of an innocent child. When Rachel stumbles upon this information (through her network of ghost friends who were introduced in the first book), she knows she must save the little girl, Elsa Spiegel. Rachel's the only one who has the bloodred key necessary for opening the gate to the Hinterland. She tries to share what's going on, but Robert is preoccupied with his social activities, and their father is still mired in grief over the loss of his wife, the kids' mother. So, using her key, Rachel bravely enters the Hinterland alone to find Elsa and bring her back. While the characterization isn't very deep, that doesn't detract much from the overall pleasure of the story, since it's more an adventure-driven than character-driven tale. The richly imagined Hinterland with its poignant but soothing portrayal of death is a bright light. Black-and-white illustrations enliven the story. Main characters read white. Both swashbuckling and emotionally stirring. (Fantasy. 8-13) Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.