Review by Booklist Review
Seventh-graders Sonnet and Zeke may be neighbors, but they don't really know each other until each chooses to interview Sonnet's grandfather for an oral-history project. Sonnet is fiercely protective of Gramps, whose wife died earlier in the year. Gramps, who responds to all their questions, perks up when answering Zeke's, perhaps because the boy listens well and asks good follow-up questions. Meanwhile, Sonnet joins the Green Club and agrees to ask the local "tree hugger," (Zeke's dad) to speak on Arbor Day. Now Zeke is miserable. Homeschooled until this year, he had hoped to find friends at school, but that's not going well, and having his very opinionated father lecture the student body is a painful prospect. With this and other examples of realistic middle-school concerns, the inviting third-person narrative shuttles back and forth between Zeke's viewpoint and Sonnet's, presenting the story from their very different perspectives before arriving at mutual understanding and a genuine alliance. Mills' imaginative story, amusing details, and true-to-life portrayals of characters and their emotions light up this enjoyable novel.
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
Mills (The Lost Language) centers characters navigating personal changes against a potent backdrop of tree conservation in this emotionally authentic novel. Until recently, seventh grader Zeke has been homeschooled by his idealistic vegan parents, who don't allow him anything "normal," such as a cellphone, video games, or television. Indiana newcomer Sonnet, also in seventh grade, arrives from Colorado with her poet mother and lively, imaginative five-year-old sister to live with her widowed grandfather. Gramps is struggling without his soulmate, to whom he proposed in the apple orchard he had to sell, which became the subdivision where Zeke lives. Only one aging apple tree--the focal point of past events and of the narrative's well-constructed momentum--remains. When Zeke and Sonnet interview Gramps for an oral history project, Zeke inadvertently derails Sonnet's mission to keep Gramps's grief at bay, and unearths a buried family tragedy. Meanwhile, Sonnet's participation in the school's Green Club threatens to reveal Zeke's "weirdo" father's environmental activism. Moving, interspersed poems, though extraneous to the plot, pay homage to a motif of trees' capacity to feel. All characters read as white. Ages 9--12. (June)
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by Horn Book Review
Seventh graders Sonnet and Zeke are neighbors who hardly know each other; even the few well-intended interactions they have dissolve into misunderstanding. Both are lonely and struggle with complicated situations at home. Sonnet and her lively little sister, Villanelle, have just moved to town with their mom to live with their grandfather after their grandmother's death. Sonnet spends considerable energy trying to keep everyone from feeling the sadness permeating their home. Meanwhile, after years of homeschooling with his zealous, overbearing father, Zeke has started public school, where he feels self-conscious about his lack of a cellphone, television, or video game console. Told in third person with alternating perspectives, the story allows readers to see how Sonnet and Zeke feel inside compared with the effect their words and actions have. Sonnet's mother is a poet, and interspersed throughout are contextual poems from the perspective of the last apple tree on Sonnet's grandfather's property. Trees, and this tree in particular, play a pivotal role in the past, present, and future of the characters and their emotional well-being. Each complex and well-meaning character suffers personal challenges and tragedies on their own, which leads to confusion, dishonesty, and further isolation. As tensions build, the characters are cornered into finally being true to one another, and they discover understanding, compassion, and release. Julie RoachJuly/August 2024 p.136 (c) Copyright The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
Two tweens and an old apple tree uncover a family secret. Sonnet and her younger sister, Villanelle, move with their single mother from Colorado to live with their maternal grandfather in Indiana. Anderson Granger is struggling to process his wife's recent death and is showing worrying signs of forgetfulness. Twelve-year-old Sonnet always wondered why they rarely visited Gramps and Nana, but Mom avoided answering her questions. Meanwhile, neighbor boy Zeke Morrison feels disconnected from his environmental journalist father. Zeke's vegan family eschews technology, which he finds frustrating. After years of home schooling, Zeke just wants to fit in at the local middle school. Both Sonnet and Zeke choose Anderson Granger as the subject of their seventh grade oral history project (much to Sonnet's annoyance). Initially unwilling partners, they grow closer as they work together, and their interviews reveal the secret behind Sonnet's mom's family estrangement. The mystery in this deftly characterized novel unravels from three different points of view--those of Sonnet, Zeke, and an old apple tree that witnessed the whole story. The personified apple tree, the last one standing in the orchard, faithfully interprets the family's story in moving poems that are interspersed throughout the novel. The tree's relationship with the family opens Zeke's eyes to the deep connection between humans and the natural world, helping to heal his relationship with his father. Main characters are coded white. A touching homage to the healing of old wounds and family relationships. (author's note) (Fiction. 8-13) Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
