Review by Booklist Review
The popular Who Was? biography series gets a makeover in the new Who HQ Graphic Novels series (4 titles). A different author and illustrator team takes on each subject, imparting an individualized artistic style for each volume while following the same basic structure: dialogue-driven panel art bookended by a short, written introduction and conclusion. Individual pages of text interject historical context when needed, and a time line and bibliography conclude. Joan of Arc's faith and determination shine through in Who Was the Girl Warrior of France?, which gives readers background on the Hundred Years War and shows Joan of Arc's challenging journey to help end it. All the books showcase the passions and urgency or risks behind their headline-making events and humanize the people who made them possible.
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by School Library Journal Review
Gr 4--6--An attempt to cast Joan of Arc as a hero falls largely flat. Though Joan's early experiences and later career are brushed in broadly, mostly in prose sections, her character is the focus of this mixed-format graphic episode. In a clear effort to make her more accessible (and perhaps more of a hero or role model) to modern young readers Searle takes liberties with history--Joan is repeatedly cast as a fighter for France's "freedom," when in fact her causes were obeying God's commands and driving the British from territory claimed by the French king. Illustrator Frantz likewise takes liberties, depicting people with a wide range of skin tones to imply an unlikely degree of racial diversity for the time and place. Still, her large-eyed, olive-hued heroine so strongly radiates grim determination and fortitude throughout that it takes a second look to notice how small she actually is next to the men around her. Joan's unshakable faith in God, herself, and her mission comes off as a steady, grinding persistence that first wears down the refusal of her local lord Robert de Baudricourt to allow her to travel to the court at Chinon, and then convinces the skeptical young Dauphin, future King Charles VII, to let her lead the relief of the English siege of Orléans. Off she rides to a destiny described (not in detail) in a conclusion that includes a time line and an audience appropriate reading list. VERDICT Conventional portraits such as Diane Stanley's or Margaret Hodges's works do Joan of Arc far better service. Not recommended.--John Peters, Children's Literature Consultant, NY
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
