In exile Rupture, reunion, and my grandmother's secret life

Sadiya Ansari

Book - 2024

"In a deeply personal investigation, award-winning journalist Sadiya Ansari takes us across three continents and back a century as she seeks the truth behind a family secret. Why did her grandmother Tahira abandon her seven children to follow a man from Karachi to a tiny village in Punjab? And though she eventually left the man, Tahira remained estranged from her children for nearly two decades. Who was she in those years when she was no longer a wife or mother? For Sadiya herself, uninterested in marriage and children, the question begets another: What space is available to women who defy cultural expectations? Through her inquiry, Sadiya discovers what her daadi's life was like during that separation and she confronts difficult ...historical truths: the pervasiveness of child marriage, how Partition made refugees of millions of families like hers, and how the national freedoms achieved in 1947 did not extend to women's lives. She sees the threads of this history woven through each generation after, and finds an unexpected sense of belonging in a culture that, at first blush, shuns women for wanting lives of their own."--

Saved in:
1 person waiting
1 copy ordered
Subjects
Genres
Biographies
Published
[Toronto, Ontario] : Anansi 2024.
Language
English
Main Author
Sadiya Ansari (author)
Physical Description
xi, 207 pages : map, genealogical table ; 22 cm
Issued also in electronic format
Bibliography
Includes bibliographical references.
ISBN
9781487012373
  • Author's Note
  • Family Tree
  • Map of India and Pakistan
  • Introduction: A Second Death
  • Chapter 1. A Clumsy Investigator
  • Chapter 2. An Unexpected Wedding
  • Chapter 3. Hardened Borders
  • Chapter 4. The First Migration
  • Chapter 5. Roots and Transplants
  • Chapter 6. The Sale
  • Chapter 7. Money Trauma
  • Chapter 8. The Break
  • Chapter 9. Road to Haroonabad
  • Chapter 10. The Second Migration
  • Chapter 11. Missing Daughters
  • Chapter 12. Kinship
  • Chapter 13. Gold
  • Chapter 141. Reunions
  • Chapter 15. Resting Place
  • Afterword: Trauma Revisited
  • Acknowledgements
  • Notes and Sources
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review

In this triumphant debut, journalist Ansari investigates a family mystery involving her grandmother. Growing up in a large Pakistani family in Toronto, Ansari had a complex relationship with her paternal grandmother, Tahira, who showed little interest in Ansari despite sharing a bedroom with her for years. The only bedtime story Tahira ever told Ansari involved a couple burdened with seven children, whose hopes for a son were never realized. The tale took on new significance when Ansari learned from an aunt that Tahira once left behind a husband and seven children for a new romance. Ten years after Tahira's death, Ansari began asking her father and other family members and friends about her grandmother's past, supplementing her interviews with research about the 1947 partition of India, which Tahira lived through. Ansari learned that, after being widowed in her early 30s, the fiercely religious Tahira pursued a second marriage that eventually fell apart. Ansari paces the account of her investigation like a crime novel, alternating first-person sections with reconstructions of Tahira's life in India and Pakistan, and drawing powerful parallels between Tahira's struggles and her own trepidations about marriage and motherhood. The result is insightful, surprising, and beautifully written. (Aug.)

(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by Kirkus Book Review

A Pakistani Canadian journalist investigates the life of her mysterious Pakistani grandmother, a woman who abandoned her family to follow a lover. Ansari never understood Tahira, the taciturn grandmother who lived with the author's family for a decade until she died. Then an aunt casually revealed that Tahira had once walked out on seven children to be with another man. The "strict code of propriety" that governed family interactions kept Ansari from asking questions. However, when she was studying journalism in graduate school, Ansari began to probe her grandmother's past through interviews with family members, historical research, and travel to Pakistan. She learned that Tahira had once dreamed of receiving an education, only to be forced into marriage at 14 to protect her family's economic interests. She became a widowed mother of seven 20 years later just as India was undergoing Partition. Her Muslim faith forced her to move north as a refugee to the new nation of Pakistan, where she struggled to raise her children. It was during this time of hardship that Tahira, lonely and without male protection, met a widower who dazzled her with his knowledge of poetry. Her eldest son, who disapproved of disregard for rules surrounding remarriage, forced her to choose between her lover and children. Tahira chose the former and endured disappointment from her lover and the pain of being separated from children she loved. Ansari succeeds in her goal to recast a vilified grandmother into a feminist heroine who struggled for self-determination in a culture that allowed her no choice. Yet as she reveals, the whole project of writing about Tahira raised many difficult issues, "inflicting damage [on loved ones] under guise of just doing my job" as an investigative reporter committed to the principles of ethical journalism. A thoughtful and informative memoir and familial investigation. Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.

Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.