Review by Booklist Review
Stayman-London's second novel posits: What if you found out your favorite fantasy book series was real? That's exactly what happens to New Yorker Tess Rosenbloom, who left her graduate program at Columbia three years ago after being sexually assaulted by a fellow grad student. Now working the night shift at a swanky hotel, Tess can't believe her eyes when she runs into Olivia Yoo, one of the glamorous vampires from her favorite book series, Blood Feud. Olivia is trying to get back to the realm known as the Isle where she, her handsome but dangerous brother Callum, and the rest of their vampire brethren have been exiled. Tess agrees to help her, only to find herself trapped on the Isle and falling into a love triangle between dashing Callum, whom the series depicts as a villain, and gregarious Felix, the series' hero. Back in New York, Tess' former best friend, Joni, who doesn't know the real reason Tess left grad school, runs across Octavia and falls hard for the charismatic vampire. Anchored by how Tess' wild adventure helps her find her inner strength and open up about her sexual assault, Stayman-London's follow-up to One to Watch (2020) is clever, richly imagined, and downright fun.
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
Stayman-London (One to Watch) turns vampire tropes on their head to address consent and healing in this sharp-witted fantasy romance. Tess Rosenbloom was a thriving doctoral student at Columbia University before her colleague Rick Keeton drugged and raped her, and panic attacks and nightmares forced her to leave campus. Three years later, Tess returns for the birthday party of Joni Chaudhari, her ex-roommate and former best friend. Unfortunately, Rick shows up and Tess flees. The night gets stranger when she discovers the world of her favorite book series, Blood Feud, is real, and the vampire Octavia Yoo needs Tess's help to deliver a message to Octavia's twin brother, Callum, who's trapped on a parallel Manhattan known as the Isle. Tess is thrilled to literally escape her reality, but her mission to reunite the vampire siblings leads her to question everything she thought she knew about Blood Feud--especially dashing Callum's role as a purported villain. Stayman makes the Blood Feud fandom feel robust through social media posts, quizzes, and book excerpts. She also sensitively handles Tess's trauma and recovery. There may be one too many subplots butting up against each other, but the center holds. Romance readers who've been involved in fantasy fandom will be especially swept away. (Oct.)
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by Library Journal Review
Three years after being sexually assaulted, Tess has a new life managing the night shift at a hotel and posting fan conspiracies about the Blood Feud novels, which she claims are based on real vampires. But only when Blood Feud character and real vampire Octavia tracks her down does Tess actually believe it herself. Then a simple message to Callum, Octavia's villanous twin, goes horribly wrong, and now Tess is stuck as the only human in a dimension of vampires. Surprisingly, the only one holding back the bloodthirsty hordes is Callum. Can Tess trust this dangerous man, and will she make it back to the real world? Stayman-London (One To Watch) builds a cleverly designed world through interstitials, fascinating side characters, and well-written friendships. The romance here is about learning to trust and be vulnerable (plus coyly written love scenes, of course), and the book is all the stronger for it. A secondary romance between Tess's friend Joni and Octavia is another highlight. VERDICT A love letter to fandom, friendship, and freedom through allowing oneself to be seen fully. Equally recommended for fantasy and romance readers.--Katherine Sleyko
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
When a hotel manager gets dropped into the world of her favorite book series, everything she thinks she knows about its so-called villain is flipped upside-down. Tess Rosenbloom hasn't had much of a life recently. Working the night shift at a Brooklyn hotel helps her manage the chronic insomnia she's been dealing with ever since a traumatic experience caused her to drop out of grad school. The only escape she's had through her biggest ups and downs are her favorite vampire books from the Blood Feud series, which she's reread so often she has entire passages committed to memory. While it's fun for Tess to playfully subscribe to the long-running theory among online fans that the island where Blood Feud takes place is real, she knows better than to take it too seriously. That all changes when Octavia Yoo, one of the vampires from the island, shows up at the hotel, knowing Tess' name and begging for her help. Soon, Tess finds herself on the isle, surrounded by vampires and feeling way out of her depth--especially once she learns that Callum, Octavia's twin and the supposed villain of the series, might actually be the good guy. As Tess spends more time with Callum, every preconceived notion she has about his character is turned on its head. Armed with new knowledge, Tess fights to bring Octavia back to the island where she belongs, even as bigger evils lurk. Meanwhile, who is August Lirio, the pseudonymous author of the Blood Feud books, and how could they have gotten the details so wrong? Stayman-London's first venture into the paranormal is paired with a dash of comedy for an injection of fun into a normally serious subgenre. That said, the plot does introduce heavier elements, such as the traumatic event in Tess' past, which creates a disjointed tone at pivotal moments. Also, spending time on a romance for Octavia back in New York detracts from the central story, when each couple could have easily received their own book. This comedic take on the vampire romance has one too many moving parts. Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.