Review by Kirkus Book Review
Journalism morphs into history in this collection of the late Irish writer's essays on the Middle East. "I met Osama bin Laden three times," writes Fisk, "once in Sudan and twice in Afghanistan, and he became a kind of albatross for me." Called on frequently after September 11 to comment on the founder of al-Qaeda, he laments not having given more credence to bin Laden's pledge to reduce the U.S. to "a shadow of itself." Still, Fisk, who reported on the Middle East forThe Independent and other UK publications for nearly half a century, allows that bin Laden had a point: the democracy-touting West came storming in after 9/11, overturning the regional balance of power. As it did so, according to his account, its actions lost any claim to the moral high ground. Fisk was one of the first to document atrocities on the part of U.S. and U.K. forces, writing sadly, "This was us. These young soldiers were our representatives in Iraq. And they had innocent blood on their hands." The overall effect of Fisk's present-tense historical writing--he holds a doctorate in history and is able to make deep connections between present and past--is to underscore the dangers of making too many assumptions about a much-assumed-about region. Suicide bombers, for instance, don't bomb for the fun of it, but neither do they do so because high on drugs, brainwashed, or insane; it's because they are committed enough to their cause to die for it. Fisk's overall conclusions, reached as the Syrian civil war blossomed, are glum: The Arab Spring is dead, the West lost, Russia and Iran won. But, he adds hopefully, "wars come to an end. And that's where history restarts." An incisive view of the Middle East that won't please the Pentagon or veterans of the Bush and Blair administrations. Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
