Review by Booklist Review
In 2022, 18-year-old Grace is grieving the death of her mother. She takes a summer job in her mother's coastal Florida hometown, transcribing archival cassette tapes for the Hermitage Historical Society. One morning, she listens to Jake Underwood, the teen volunteer who recorded the tapes in 1991, read the founding document of Hurricane Club, established in 1968. Jake goes off-script when he sees his uncle's name; no one knew why his uncle Charley went out in the storm that killed him, but other members of the club must have been there. Who were they, and why did they bury the truth? Grace records a response, launching a correspondence across time. As Grace investigates and learns that Jake also died in a hurricane in 1992, she needs to make a decision: can she stand up to the families holding onto their secrets and save Jake? DeWitt shines with a character-driven, emotional mystery that tests the veil between past and present. Intriguingly supernatural, this moving novel on grief and healing features supportive, platonic friendships and a protagonist worth rooting for.
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
Six months after her mother's death, 18-year-old Grace Crain spends the summer in her mother's hometown of Hermitage, Fla. While working as an intern at the local historical society, she transcribes cassette tapes recorded in the '90s by a boy her age, Jake Underwood. She soon realizes that if she records herself speaking on the other side of the tapes, Jake can hear her 30 years in the past. The two begin talking, and as they bond over their parallel experiences with grief, they also uncover a secret lying beneath the surface of Hermitage--one that spans five decades and involves some of the most important people in town, who may have played a part in the deaths of Jake's father and uncle. Through Grace's assuredly written voice, DeWitt (Wren Martin Ruins It All) deftly balances an examination of grief and healing with a gradually unfolding small-town mystery. Though Grace's relationships with other major supporting characters--such as her cousin and a coworker--are somewhat threadbare, the story stands out in its depiction of emotional intellect; intriguing supernatural elements add texture. Grace cues as white; the secondary cast is intersectionally diverse. Ages 14--up. Agent: Cate Hart, Harvey Klinger Literary. (Feb.)
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by School Library Journal Review
Gr 9 Up--Escaping her grief, 18-year-old Grace runs away to her late mother's Florida hometown to mindlessly digitize cassette tapes at Hermitage's local Historical Society. What's startling is that Grace realizes she can directly communicate with Jake Underwood, the teen who originally recorded the tapes in the early 1990s. She's soon even more disturbed to find no one in this small town seems to remember Jake. Surrounded by unfamiliar, possibly untrustworthy, locals and extended family, Grace begins to work with Jake to uncover what secrets Hermitage is hiding. DeWitt delivers a disquieting tale of secrets filled with a legacy of lies that burdens each generation in Hermitage. The question of morality while one faces mortality is a running theme as Grace uncovers the mystery and connection surrounding the Underwood boys' disappearances in the 1970s and 1990s. Grace and Jake are both suffering the loss of a parent which is made all too real as both accurately describe the solitude and grieving process. The dirty town secret leads to Grace and Jake building a friendship that helps them confront their guilt and sorrow while discovering true connection. Though an explanation for how the tapes transcend time is left up to readers, they will be moved to root for Grace even through the somber, unsatisfying ending. Grace and Jake read seemingly white while there is some diversity in the extended cast. VERDICT A time-bending, twisted tale that will intrigue readers needing reassurance in grief while unraveling a mystery.--Emily Walker
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
A grieving teen travels to the small town her late mother was from in this mystery that's shot through with strands of speculative fiction. Since the accident six months earlier that killed her mom and seriously injured her, 18-year-old Grace Crain has been nursing scars, both literal and figurative. Spending the summer at her uncle Aaron's in Hermitage, Florida, appeals in part because her mother never went back to her hometown, so it doesn't hold painful memories of her for Grace. However, she's unprepared for how many people she's never met seem to be aware of her. Grace gets to know first cousin Lara and third cousin Griffin, with whom she's working at the municipal historical society. But when she's assigned to transcribe cassette tapes recorded in the early 1990s by Jake Underwood, a boy who was around her age, Grace discovers something startling: She can communicate with Jake through the tapes--and in the process, she learns that the sleepy town is harboring many secrets. The teens' ability to communicate across time simply exists with no real explanation. The engaging mystery surrounding a natural disaster and a tragic death propels the story toward its distinctly understated ending, but the real focus is on the friendship Grace forms with Jake. Grace presents white; there's some racial diversity among the secondary characters, including Lara, who has "dark tan" skin from her mom. An intriguing blend of thrilling and more quiet and contemplative elements.(Mystery. 13-18) Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
